Awadallah Nida, Vaughan Aaron, Franco Kathleen, Munir Farah, Sharaby Na'ama, Goldfarb Johanna
Cleveland Clinic Foundation, Cleveland, OH, USA.
Child Abuse Negl. 2005 Aug;29(8):931-41. doi: 10.1016/j.chiabu.2004.11.007.
The history of an older child victim of Munchausen by proxy (MBP) is described. He was referred for evaluation after repeated sinus surgeries for recurrent sinus infections believed to be related to a falsified history of an immunodeficiency. The perpetrator was the mother of this 14-year-old victim, consistent with the majority of such cases. This case prompted a review of cases of MBP in older children reported in our hospital as well as a literature search for other cases in older children.
This study was a chart review of children over 6 years of age who had been evaluated by social services at the Children's Hospital at the Cleveland Clinic and reported as cases of Munchausen by proxy to Child Protective Services between January 2001 and June 2003. Also, an OVID, Psychline, and Pubmed literature review of published cases of Munchausen by proxy were identified, and cases occurring in the older child were selected for review.
Older children who are the victims of Munchausen by proxy may have an induced illness, but falsified reports of symptoms and medical history to coerce the child to undergo medical procedures may be more common. Collusion of the victim with the perpetrator may also become a factor as the child ages and adopts the deception. Given the complex relationship that exists between the parent and child, it is difficult to predict whether the victim either will assist the caregiver in maintaining the factitious illness or be able to recognize the falsification.
Older children who are the victims of Munchausen by proxy may fear consequences of revealing the factitious illness. Physicians must consider the possibility of this diagnosis whenever there are discrepancies in a child's illness that makes a factitious illness a consideration.
本文描述了一名年龄稍大的代理孟乔森综合征(MBP)受害儿童的病史。该患儿因反复出现鼻窦感染,在接受多次鼻窦手术后被转诊评估,这些感染被认为与伪造的免疫缺陷病史有关。犯罪者是这名14岁受害者的母亲,这与大多数此类案例一致。该病例促使我们回顾了我院报告的年龄稍大儿童的MBP病例,并对其他年龄稍大儿童的病例进行了文献检索。
本研究对2001年1月至2003年6月间在克利夫兰诊所儿童医院接受社会服务评估,并被作为代理孟乔森综合征病例报告给儿童保护服务机构的6岁以上儿童进行了病历回顾。此外,通过OVID、Psychline和Pubmed对已发表的代理孟乔森综合征病例进行文献检索,选取年龄稍大儿童的病例进行回顾。
代理孟乔森综合征的大龄受害儿童可能患有诱发性疾病,但为迫使孩子接受医疗程序而伪造症状和病史报告的情况可能更为常见。随着孩子年龄增长并接受这种欺骗行为,受害者与犯罪者的勾结也可能成为一个因素。鉴于父母与孩子之间存在的复杂关系,很难预测受害者是会协助照顾者维持这种虚构疾病,还是能够识别这种伪造行为。
代理孟乔森综合征的大龄受害儿童可能担心揭露虚构疾病的后果。每当儿童疾病存在差异,使虚构疾病成为一种考虑因素时,医生必须考虑到这种诊断的可能性。