Hershman Dawn, McBride Russell, Jacobson Judith S, Lamerato Lois, Roberts Kevin, Grann Victor R, Neugut Alfred I
Department of Medicine and the Herbert Irving Comprehensive Cancer Center, College of Physicians and Surgeons, New York, NY, USA.
J Clin Oncol. 2005 Sep 20;23(27):6639-46. doi: 10.1200/JCO.2005.12.633.
Black women with breast cancer are known to have poorer survival than white women. Suboptimal treatment may compromise the survival benefits of adjuvant chemotherapy. We analyzed the association of race and survival with duration of treatment and number of treatment cycles among women receiving chemotherapy for early-stage breast cancer.
Patients were women in the Henry Ford Health System tumor registry who were diagnosed with stage I/II breast cancer between January 1, 1996, and December 31, 2001, who received adjuvant chemotherapy. We calculated an observed/expected ratio of treatment duration and of completed chemotherapy cycles for each patient. Using Cox proportional hazards models, we analyzed the association of early treatment termination and treatment duration with all-cause mortality, controlling for age, race, stage, hormone receptor status, grade, comorbidity score, and doxorubicin use.
Of 472 eligible patients, 28% (31% black, 23% white; P = .03) received fewer cycles of treatment than expected. Black race, receipt of < or = 75% of the expected number of cycles, increasing age, hormone receptor negativity, and a comorbidity score of more than 1 were associated with poorer survival. Among the 344 patients receiving the expected number of cycles, 60% experienced delays. These delays did not reduce survival.
This study is the first to find that a substantial fraction of women with early-stage breast cancer terminated their chemotherapy prematurely and that early termination was associated with both black race and poorer survival. A better understanding of the determinants of suboptimal treatment may lead to interventions that can reduce racial disparities and improve breast cancer outcomes for all women.
已知患有乳腺癌的黑人女性比白人女性的生存率更低。治疗不充分可能会影响辅助化疗的生存获益。我们分析了早期乳腺癌化疗女性中种族、生存与治疗持续时间及治疗周期数之间的关联。
患者为亨利福特健康系统肿瘤登记处中在1996年1月1日至2001年12月31日期间被诊断为I/II期乳腺癌且接受辅助化疗的女性。我们计算了每位患者治疗持续时间和完成化疗周期数的观察值/期望值之比。使用Cox比例风险模型,我们分析了早期治疗终止和治疗持续时间与全因死亡率之间的关联,并对年龄、种族、分期、激素受体状态、分级、合并症评分和阿霉素使用情况进行了控制。
在472名符合条件的患者中,28%(黑人占31%,白人占23%;P = 0.03)接受的治疗周期数少于预期。黑人种族、接受的周期数小于或等于预期数的75%、年龄增加、激素受体阴性以及合并症评分大于1与较差的生存率相关。在344名接受预期周期数治疗的患者中,60%经历了延迟。这些延迟并未降低生存率。
本研究首次发现相当一部分早期乳腺癌女性过早终止化疗,且早期终止与黑人种族及较差的生存率均相关。更好地了解治疗不充分的决定因素可能会带来干预措施,从而减少种族差异并改善所有女性的乳腺癌治疗结果。