Suzuki Takefumi, Watanabe Koichiro, Yagi Gohei, Kashima Haruo
Keio University, School of Medicine, Department of Neuropsychiatry, Japan.
Nihon Shinkei Seishin Yakurigaku Zasshi. 2005 Aug;25(4):159-68.
The role of antipsychotic polypharmacy in the treatment of schizophrenia remains largely unknown, although such a mode of therapy has frequently been advocated on an empirical basis. This trend has especially been true in Japan. We briefly review current evidence in favor of and against polypharmacy in schizophrenia, then we show the data of revising antipsychotic polypharmacy to monotherapy. The study included 47 patients with chronic schizophrenia. Among the 44 patients assessable, 24 remained stable, 10 got better and 10 got worse after 24 weeks of maintenance monotherapy with the main agent. Overall, there were no significant differences in the Global Assessment of Functioning and the Global Impression of the participants. Conversion to antipsychotic monotherapy was feasible in 22 patients, while another 12 needed low dosages of low-potency agents. The chlorpromazine equivalent amount of antipsychotics was significantly reduced from 1,171 to 952 mg/day in 34 patients who were successful in switching. Although the procedure overall did not help patients much, it is suggested that many instances of antipsychotic polypharmacy are avoidable. Adding medications upon the emergence of symptoms might be an easy way to treat patients. Such an action should be validated in every case, however, and polypharmacy should be tested against prolonged, tenacious monotherapy.
尽管基于经验经常提倡采用联合使用抗精神病药物的治疗方式,但这种联合用药在精神分裂症治疗中的作用在很大程度上仍不明确。这种趋势在日本尤为明显。我们简要回顾了目前支持和反对精神分裂症联合用药的证据,然后展示了将联合使用抗精神病药物改为单一用药的数据。该研究纳入了47例慢性精神分裂症患者。在44例可评估的患者中,使用主要药物进行24周维持单一治疗后,24例病情稳定,10例病情好转,10例病情恶化。总体而言,参与者的功能总体评定量表和总体印象评分没有显著差异。22例患者成功转换为单一使用抗精神病药物治疗,而另外12例需要低剂量的低效价药物。34例成功换药的患者,抗精神病药物的氯丙嗪等效剂量从每天1171毫克显著降至952毫克。尽管总体过程对患者帮助不大,但提示许多联合使用抗精神病药物的情况是可以避免的。在症状出现时加用药物可能是治疗患者的一种简便方法。然而,这种做法在每种情况下都应得到验证,并且联合用药应与长期、持续的单一治疗进行对比试验。