Hvannberg Jónas, Róbertsson Grétar O, Gestsson Júlíus, Ingvarsson Thornorvaldur
Akureyri University Hospital, 600 Akureyri, Iceland.
Laeknabladid. 2005 Oct;91(10):739-46.
Osteoarthrosis (OA) is a growing medical problem in western societies and the cost of the treatment has grown accordingly in the last years. Patients with OA often need to be operated on with arthroplasties and one important outcome measure for this type of surgery is the revision rate. The purpose of this study was to assess the results of knee arthroplasties performed at Akureyri University Hospital during 1983-2003, with special emphasis on revision rates, infections and other complications.
Information was gathered from journals of the 457 patients who underwent knee arthroplasties during 1983-2003. Information about the operation and hospital stay was recorded as well as if patients later became the subject of revision. CRR (cumulative revision rate) uses survival statistics to estimate the risk of revision after primary operation and was calculated for patients with OA operated on with knee arthroplasty. Statistical informations were calculated in Microsoft Excel. Kaplan Mayer analysis was used to calculate the CRR and that was done in SPSS 11.5.
560 primary operations were performed during the period, 515 total knee arthroplasties and 45 unicompartmental. 200 operations were performed on males and 360 on females. Mean ages for males was 70.8 years and for females 69.4 years. Revision rates varied depending on the type of implant. Twelve unicompartmental and 28 total knee arthroplasties became subject of revision. The PCA unicompartmental prosthesis most frequently needed revision, or in over 50% of cases. The CRR for the AGC total knee prosthesis was the lowest or around 3% at seven years, including revisions due to infections. Revisions due to infections were three in the period or 0.6% of all the total knee arthroplasties. Complications that substantially increase the risk of revision and/or are life-threatening were recorded in 1.8% of the operations at the time of discharge. Only one patient had pulmonary embolism (0.2%) and two patients (0.4%) had deep venous thrombosis.
Our high revision rate for the PCA implant is consistent with what has been seen in other studies. This prosthesis was found to have mechanical problems and was withdrawn from the market. Our revision rate for the AGC implant as well as the rate of infections are low and the results are quite comparable to what has been found in Sweden by the Swedish Knee Arthroplasty Registry. The results of knee arthroplasties performed at Akureyri University Hospital, regarding revision rates, infections and complications, are fully comparable to other known results internationally.
骨关节炎(OA)在西方社会正成为一个日益严重的医学问题,其治疗费用在过去几年也相应增加。OA患者常常需要接受关节置换手术,而这类手术的一项重要疗效指标是翻修率。本研究的目的是评估1983年至2003年期间在阿库雷里大学医院进行的膝关节置换手术的结果,特别关注翻修率、感染及其他并发症。
收集了1983年至2003年期间接受膝关节置换手术的457例患者的病历资料。记录了手术及住院情况,以及患者后来是否成为翻修对象。累积翻修率(CRR)采用生存统计学方法来估计初次手术后的翻修风险,并针对接受膝关节置换手术的OA患者进行计算。统计信息在Microsoft Excel中计算。采用Kaplan - Mayer分析计算CRR,这在SPSS 11.5中完成。
在此期间共进行了560例初次手术,其中515例全膝关节置换术和45例单髁置换术。男性患者手术200例,女性患者手术360例。男性患者的平均年龄为70.8岁,女性患者为69.4岁。翻修率因植入物类型而异。12例单髁置换术和28例全膝关节置换术需要翻修。PCA单髁假体最常需要翻修,超过50%的病例如此。AGC全膝关节假体的CRR在7年时最低,约为3%,包括因感染导致的翻修。在此期间因感染导致的翻修有3例,占所有全膝关节置换术的0.6%。出院时,1.8%的手术记录了显著增加翻修风险和/或危及生命的并发症。仅有1例患者发生肺栓塞(0.2%),2例患者(0.4%)发生深静脉血栓形成。
我们PCA植入物的高翻修率与其他研究结果一致。发现该假体存在机械问题,已退出市场。我们AGC植入物的翻修率以及感染率较低,结果与瑞典膝关节置换登记处瑞典的研究结果相当。阿库雷里大学医院进行的膝关节置换手术在翻修率、感染和并发症方面的结果与国际上其他已知结果完全可比。