Lock R J, Pengiran Tengah D S N A, Unsworth D J, Ward J J, Wills A J
Immunology and Immunogenetics, North Bristol NHS Trust, Southmead Hospital, UK.
J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry. 2005 Nov;76(11):1601-3. doi: 10.1136/jnnp.2004.058487.
Some authors contend that patients with idiopathic neurological disease who are also anti-gliadin antibody seropositive are gluten sensitive. However, anti-gliadin antibodies lack disease specificity being found in 10% of healthy blood donors. We report a study comparing anti-gliadin antibody with other food antibodies in patients with idiopathic ataxia (20), hereditary ataxias (seven), or idiopathic peripheral neuropathy (32). Patients were HLA typed. IgA anti-tissue transglutaminase antibodies (tTG) were measured. No case was positive for IgA anti-tTG making occult coeliac disease unlikely. HLA DQ2 and HLA DQ8 were found distributed equally across all patient groups and unrelated to gliadin antibody status. HLA DQ2 expressing, anti-gliadin antibody positive cases (so called "gluten ataxia") were rare in our clinics (four cases in 2 years from a population of 2 million). We conclude that coeliac disease per se is not commonly associated with either idiopathic ataxia or idiopathic peripheral neuropathy. Our study also casts doubt on the nosological status of "gluten ataxia" as a discreet disease entity. All food antibodies tested, particularly IgG, were a common finding in both ataxia and peripheral neuropathy groups. No particular food antibody was associated with any patient group. Food antibodies were equally common in hereditary ataxias. We conclude they are a non-specific finding.
一些作者认为,患有特发性神经疾病且抗麦醇溶蛋白抗体血清呈阳性的患者对麸质敏感。然而,抗麦醇溶蛋白抗体缺乏疾病特异性,在10%的健康献血者中也能检测到。我们报告了一项研究,比较了特发性共济失调患者(20例)、遗传性共济失调患者(7例)或特发性周围神经病患者(32例)的抗麦醇溶蛋白抗体与其他食物抗体。对患者进行了HLA分型。检测了IgA抗组织转谷氨酰胺酶抗体(tTG)。没有一例患者的IgA抗tTG呈阳性,因此隐匿性乳糜泻的可能性不大。发现HLA DQ2和HLA DQ8在所有患者组中分布均匀,且与麦醇溶蛋白抗体状态无关。在我们的诊所中,表达HLA DQ2且抗麦醇溶蛋白抗体呈阳性的病例(即所谓的“麸质共济失调”)很少见(在2年中,从200万人口中发现4例)。我们得出结论,乳糜泻本身通常与特发性共济失调或特发性周围神经病无关。我们的研究也对“麸质共济失调”作为一种独立疾病实体的疾病分类学地位提出了质疑。所检测的所有食物抗体,尤其是IgG,在共济失调组和周围神经病组中都是常见的发现。没有特定的食物抗体与任何患者组相关。食物抗体在遗传性共济失调中同样常见。我们得出结论,它们是一种非特异性发现。