Van Lierde Kristiane M, Vinck Bart, De Ley Sofia, Clement Gregory, Van Cauwenberge Paul
Department of Otorhinolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery and Speech and Language, Ghent University, Dienst Logopedie 2P1, De Pintelaan 185, 9000 Ghent, Belgium.
J Voice. 2005 Dec;19(4):511-8. doi: 10.1016/j.jvoice.2004.10.005.
The main purpose of this study was to determine the vocal quality characteristics among the 45 monozygotic cotwins (MT). As the performance of the voice is related to several genetically determined anatomical and physiological factors, the authors hypothesized that the vocal characteristics and the overall vocal quality by means of the Dysphonia Severity Index (DSI) will be identical in MT. An additional objective of this study was to determine whether sex and age influence vocal similarities in MT and to compare the voice characteristics of MT with the normative data of unrelated peers. As more environmental factors influence the aging of the voice, age-related differences were expected. No sex-related differences were expected. Subjective and objective assessment techniques determined the vocal quality. No significant differences were obtained, and most comparisons resulted in significant correlation coefficients. For the acoustic parameters jitter and shimmer only, no significant correlation coefficients could be obtained. It is clear that the perceptual voice characteristics, the laryngeal aerodynamic measurements of maximum phonation time (MPT), the vocal performances, and the overall vocal quality by means of the DSI are similar in MT. These vocal characteristics are not influenced either by the subjects' age or sex and are situated within the normative range of unrelated peers. To what extent other aspects (environment, anxiety, tension, etc) might play a role in the acoustical dimensions regarding frequency and amplitude perturbation, which were in the normal range, is a subject of further research.
本研究的主要目的是确定45对同卵双胞胎(MT)的嗓音质量特征。由于嗓音表现与多种由基因决定的解剖学和生理学因素相关,作者推测,通过嗓音障碍严重程度指数(DSI)得出的嗓音特征和总体嗓音质量在同卵双胞胎中是相同的。本研究的另一个目的是确定性别和年龄是否会影响同卵双胞胎的嗓音相似性,并将同卵双胞胎的嗓音特征与不相关同龄人的标准数据进行比较。由于更多环境因素会影响嗓音的老化,因此预计会存在与年龄相关的差异。预计不存在与性别相关的差异。主观和客观评估技术确定了嗓音质量。未获得显著差异,大多数比较得出了显著的相关系数。仅对于声学参数抖动和闪烁,未获得显著的相关系数。很明显,同卵双胞胎在感知嗓音特征、最大发声时间(MPT)的喉部空气动力学测量、嗓音表现以及通过DSI得出的总体嗓音质量方面是相似的。这些嗓音特征不受受试者年龄或性别的影响,且处于不相关同龄人标准范围内。在正常范围内的频率和幅度微扰的声学维度方面,其他方面(环境、焦虑、紧张等)可能在多大程度上起作用,是进一步研究的课题。