Marel Miloslav, Pekarek Zdenek, Spasova Irena, Pafko Pavel, Schutzner Jan, Betka Jan, Pospisil Ronald
Pulmonary Department of the 1st Medical Faculty, Charles University, Katerinska 19, Prague 2, 120-00 Czech Republic.
Respiration. 2005 Nov-Dec;72(6):622-8. doi: 10.1159/000089578.
Clinically significant benign stenoses of the large airways develop in about 1% of patients after intubation. The management of benign stenoses is not unified around the world, nor are there any accepted methods for their screening.
The purpose of this study is to describe and compare results of interventional bronchoscopy and surgical therapy of benign stenoses as well as to propose an algorithm for the management of this airways disorder.
Prospective study on 80 consecutive patients with benign stenoses of the large airways admitted to the Pulmonary Department of the University Hospital of Prague-Motol.
Sixty-two patients developed stenoses after endotracheal intubation or tracheostomy, in 18 patients the stenosis was caused by other diseases or pathological situations. Thirty-eight patients were sent for surgical resection of the stenotic part of the airways. 2 surgically treated patients developed recurrence of the stenosis and had to be reoperated on. Narrowing of the trachea at the site of end-to-end anastomosis developed in 6 other patients and was cured by interventional bronchoscopy. The remaining 42 patients were treated by interventional bronchoscopy (Nd-YAG laser, electrocautery, stent) which was curative in 35 patients. Sixty-five patients were alive at the time of evaluation, 15 patients died. Five of them died between 3 and 14 (median 4) months after surgery from a disease other than airway stenosis. Ten nonresected patients also died, with 1 exception, due to a disease other than airway stenosis; the median survival was 9 months.
We recommend to assess the patient for surgery after the initial diagnosis and therapeutic bronchoscopy with dilatation of the stenosis. If the patient is not a suitable candidate for resection, interventional bronchoscopy is an appropriate alternative for the management of benign stenoses of the large airways.
大约1%的插管患者会出现具有临床意义的大气道良性狭窄。全球对于良性狭窄的处理并不统一,也没有公认的筛查方法。
本研究旨在描述和比较良性狭窄的介入性支气管镜检查和手术治疗结果,并提出一种针对这种气道疾病的处理算法。
对布拉格-莫托尔大学医院肺科收治的80例连续性大气道良性狭窄患者进行前瞻性研究。
62例患者在气管插管或气管切开术后出现狭窄,18例患者的狭窄由其他疾病或病理情况引起。38例患者被送去手术切除气道狭窄部分。2例接受手术治疗的患者出现狭窄复发,不得不再次手术。另外6例患者在端端吻合部位出现气管狭窄,通过介入性支气管镜检查治愈。其余42例患者接受介入性支气管镜检查(钕钇铝石榴石激光、电灼、支架),其中35例治愈。评估时65例患者存活,15例患者死亡。其中5例在术后3至14个月(中位时间4个月)死于气道狭窄以外的疾病。10例未接受手术的患者也死亡,除1例例外,均死于气道狭窄以外的疾病;中位生存期为9个月。
我们建议在初步诊断和对狭窄进行扩张的治疗性支气管镜检查后对患者进行手术评估。如果患者不适合手术切除,介入性支气管镜检查是治疗大气道良性狭窄的合适替代方法。