Johnson Kristina T, Johnson C Daniel, Fletcher Joel G, MacCarty Robert L, Summers Ronald L
Department of Radiology, Mayo Clinic Rochester, 200 First Street SW, Rochester, MN 55905, USA.
AJR Am J Roentgenol. 2006 Jan;186(1):90-5. doi: 10.2214/AJR.04.1658.
Using a 3D rendering technique called "virtual dissection," we sought to evaluate polyp and fold distortion using a colon phantom, estimate the polyp detection performance in humans, and estimate the added benefit of double interpretation and computer-aided diagnosis.
A colon phantom containing 144 polyps of varying sizes (5-12 mm) and shapes (flat, sessile, pedunculated) was scanned. Polyp shape and distortion at virtual dissection were categorized as flame, club, pea, or bizarre. Haustral fold distortion was graded. The CT colonography examinations in 20 consecutive patients (colonoscopically proven normal findings, n = 5; polyps > or = 1 cm, n = 17 in 15 patients) were blindly reviewed by three radiologists using the virtual dissection technique. The added benefits of double interpretation and computer-aided diagnosis were tabulated.
Sessile polyps appeared flame (35/48 [73%]) or pea (11/48 [23%]) in shape. Flat polyps appeared flame-shaped (31/47 [66%]) or pea-shaped (16/47 [34%]). Pedunculated polyps were flame (15/45 [33%]), club (20/45 [44%]), or pea (6/45 [13%]) in shape. Axial distortion occurred along the longitudinal axis. The sensitivities of the three observers for polyps of 1 cm or more were 16/17 (94%), 14/17 (82%), and 15/17 (88%). The specificities were 5/5 (100%), 5/5 (100%), and 4/5 (80%). Sensitivities after double interpretation and computer-aided diagnosis improved but did not reach statistical significance.
Although distortion of colonic structures exists at virtual dissection, it does so in recognizable patterns, so that sensitivity for polyp detection is not compromised.
使用一种名为“虚拟解剖”的三维渲染技术,我们试图通过结肠模型评估息肉和皱襞变形情况,估计在人体中息肉的检测性能,并估计双重解读和计算机辅助诊断的附加益处。
扫描一个含有144个大小各异(5 - 12毫米)、形状不同(扁平、无蒂、有蒂)息肉的结肠模型。虚拟解剖时息肉的形状和变形情况分为火焰状、棒状、豌豆状或奇异状。结肠袋皱襞变形进行分级。由三位放射科医生使用虚拟解剖技术对20例连续患者的CT结肠成像检查(经结肠镜检查证实正常结果的有5例;息肉≥1厘米的患者有15例,共17个息肉)进行盲法评估。将双重解读和计算机辅助诊断的附加益处制成表格。
无蒂息肉呈火焰状(35/48 [73%])或豌豆状(11/48 [23%])。扁平息肉呈火焰状(31/47 [66%])或豌豆状(16/47 [34%])。有蒂息肉呈火焰状(15/45 [33%])、棒状(20/45 [44%])或豌豆状(6/45 [13%])。轴向变形沿纵轴发生。三位观察者对1厘米及以上息肉的敏感度分别为16/17(94%)、14/17(82%)和15/17(88%)。特异度分别为5/5(100%)、5/5(100%)和4/5(80%)。双重解读和计算机辅助诊断后的敏感度有所提高,但未达到统计学意义。
尽管在虚拟解剖时结肠结构存在变形,但变形模式是可识别的,因此对息肉检测的敏感度并未受到影响。