Rais D, Nowack B, Schulin R, Luster J
Swiss Federal Institute for Forest, Snow and Landscape Research (WSL), CH-8903 Birmensdorf, Switzerland.
J Environ Qual. 2006 Jan 3;35(1):50-60. doi: 10.2134/jeq2005.0040. Print 2006 Jan-Feb.
Both the bioavailability of a trace metal (TM) in a soil and the risk of leaching to the ground water are linked to the metals concentration in the soil solution. Sampling soil solution by tension lysimetry with suction cups is a simple and established technique that is increasingly used for monitoring dissolved TM in soils. Of major concern, however, is the sorption of TM by the walls of the samplers. Metal sorption by different materials used in suction cups can vary widely, depending also on the chemistry of the soil solution. We compared the sorption of Cu, Zn, Cd, and Pb by different standard-size and micro suction cups in the laboratory at two pH values (4.5 and 7.5 or 8.0) in absence and presence of dissolved organic carbon (DOC). In addition, we investigated the sorption of DOC from different origins by the cup materials. At both pH values, the weakest sorption of all four TMs was exhibited by standard-size suction cups based on nylon membranes and by hollow fibers made from polyvinyl alcohol (PVA). At alkaline pH, borosilicate glass, ceramic materials, and polytetrafluorethylene (PTFE) mixed with silicate were characterized by generally strong sorption of all investigated TMs. In addition, Cu and Pb were strongly sorbed at low pH by PTFE-silicate and a ceramic material used for the construction of standard-size suction cups. On the other hand, sorption of Cu, Zn, and Cd by ceramic capillaries produced from pure aluminum oxide was negligible at low pH. Micro suction cups made of an unknown polymerous tube sorbed Cu strongly, but were well suited to monitor Zn, Cd, and Pb at low pH, and, in the presence of DOC, also at high pH. Major cations (Na+, Mg2+, K+, Ca2+) and anions (Cl-, NO3-, SO4(2-)) were not or very weakly sorbed by all cup materials, except for Mg2+, K+, and Ca2+ by borosilicate glass at pH 7.5. Trace metal sorption by suction cups was generally greatly reduced in the presence of DOC, especially at alkaline pH. The sorption of DOC itself depended on its source. Dissolved organic carbon from leaf litter extracts with a probably large hydrophobic fraction was sorbed more strongly than mainly hydrophilic DOC from a mineral soil solution.
土壤中微量金属(TM)的生物有效性以及向地下水淋溶的风险都与土壤溶液中的金属浓度相关。使用带吸盘的张力溶渗仪采集土壤溶液是一种简单且成熟的技术,越来越多地用于监测土壤中溶解态的TM。然而,主要问题在于采样器壁对TM的吸附作用。吸盘所使用的不同材料对金属的吸附差异很大,这也取决于土壤溶液的化学性质。我们在实验室中比较了不同标准尺寸和微型吸盘在两种pH值(4.5和7.5或8.0)下,在不存在和存在溶解有机碳(DOC)的情况下,对铜、锌、镉和铅的吸附情况。此外,我们还研究了不同来源的DOC被吸盘材料的吸附情况。在这两种pH值下,基于尼龙膜的标准尺寸吸盘和由聚乙烯醇(PVA)制成的中空纤维对所有四种TM的吸附最弱。在碱性pH条件下,硼硅酸盐玻璃、陶瓷材料以及与硅酸盐混合的聚四氟乙烯(PTFE)对所有研究的TM通常表现出较强的吸附。此外,在低pH值下,PTFE - 硅酸盐和用于制造标准尺寸吸盘的一种陶瓷材料对铜和铅有强烈吸附。另一方面,由纯氧化铝制成的陶瓷毛细管在低pH值下对铜、锌和镉的吸附可忽略不计。由未知聚合物管制成的微型吸盘对铜有强烈吸附,但在低pH值下非常适合监测锌、镉和铅,并且在存在DOC的情况下,在高pH值下也适用。除了在pH值为7.5时硼硅酸盐玻璃对镁离子、钾离子和钙离子有吸附外,所有吸盘材料对主要阳离子(钠离子 +、镁离子2 +、钾离子 +、钙离子2 +)和阴离子(氯离子 -、硝酸根离子 -、硫酸根离子2 -)的吸附都很弱或几乎没有吸附。在存在DOC的情况下,尤其是在碱性pH条件下,吸盘对痕量金属的吸附通常会大大降低。DOC本身的吸附取决于其来源。来自落叶提取物且可能具有较大疏水部分的溶解有机碳比来自矿质土壤溶液的主要为亲水性的DOC吸附更强。