Morad Mohammed, Shvarts Shifra, Merrick Joav, Borkan Jeffrey
Clalit Health Service, Beer-Sheva, Israel.
ScientificWorldJournal. 2006 Jan 24;6:81-95. doi: 10.1100/tsw.2006.06.
The extension of universal health service insurance to national populations is a relatively new phenomenon. Since 1995, the Israeli National Health Insurance Law (NHIL) has provided universal health services to every resident, but the effect of this law on health and health services among minorities has not been examined sufficiently. The goals of this study were to track some of the first changes engendered by the NHIL among the Negev Bedouin Arabs to examine the effects of universal health care services. Methods included analysis of historical and health policy documents, three field appraisals of health care services (1994, 1995, 1999), a region-wide interview survey of Negev Bedouins (1997), and key informant interviews. For the interview survey, a sample of 515 households was chosen from different Bedouin localities representing major sedentarization stages. Results showed that prior to the NHIL, a substantial proportion of the Negev Bedouins were uninsured with limited, locally available health service. Since 1995, health services, particularly primary care clinics and health manpower, have dramatically expanded. The initial expansion appears to have been a marketing ploy, but real improvements have occurred. There was a high level of health service utilization among the Bedouins in the Negev, especially private medical services, hospitals, and night ambulatory medical services. The NHIL brought change to the structure of health services in Israel, namely the institution of a national health system based on proportional allocation of resources (based on size and age) and open competition in the provision of quality health care. The expansion of the pool of potential members engendered by the new universal coverage had profound effects on the Health Funds' attitudes towards Negev Bedouins. In addition, real consumer choice was introduced for the first time. Although all the health care needs of this rapidly growing population have yet to be met fully, the assurances under the Law and the new level of competition promise a higher level of service in the future.
全民健康服务保险覆盖全国人口是一个相对较新的现象。自1995年以来,以色列《国家健康保险法》(NHIL)为每位居民提供全民健康服务,但该法律对少数群体的健康和健康服务的影响尚未得到充分研究。本研究的目的是追踪NHIL在纳杰夫贝都因阿拉伯人中引发的一些最初变化,以检验全民医疗服务的效果。方法包括分析历史和卫生政策文件、对医疗服务进行三次实地评估(1994年、1995年、1999年)、对纳杰夫贝都因人进行全地区访谈调查(1997年)以及关键信息提供者访谈。对于访谈调查,从代表主要定居阶段的不同贝都因地区选取了515户家庭作为样本。结果显示,在NHIL实施之前,很大一部分纳杰夫贝都因人没有保险,只能获得有限的当地医疗服务。自1995年以来,医疗服务,尤其是初级保健诊所和卫生人力大幅增加。最初的扩张似乎是一种营销策略,但确实有了实际改善。内盖夫的贝都因人对医疗服务利用率很高,尤其是私人医疗服务、医院和夜间门诊医疗服务。NHIL给以色列的医疗服务结构带来了变化,即建立了一个基于资源按比例分配(根据规模和年龄)以及在提供优质医疗服务方面展开公开竞争的国家医疗体系。新的全民覆盖带来的潜在成员数量增加,对健康基金对待内盖夫贝都因人的态度产生了深远影响。此外,首次引入了真正的消费者选择。尽管这个快速增长的群体的所有医疗需求尚未得到充分满足,但法律保障和新的竞争水平有望在未来提供更高水平的服务。