MacDonald J D, Hendershot W H
Department of Natural Resource Sciences, McGill University-MacDonald Campus, 21,111 Lakeshore Road, Ste Anne de Bellevue, QC, Canada H9X 3V9.
Environ Pollut. 2006 Sep;143(2):228-40. doi: 10.1016/j.envpol.2005.11.031. Epub 2006 Jan 30.
Trace metal (TM) mobility and toxicity varies with changing soil conditions. Geochemical models can account for the influence of soil characteristics on TM behaviour. We tested the effectiveness of the Stockholm humic model (SHM), and the NICA-Donnan model (NDM) to estimate partitioning coefficients (logKd) in 26 forest floor horizons of podzolic soils enriched in trace metals from deposition by metal smelters. We wanted to know if a consistent approach could be applied to model metal partitioning in forest floors without optimizing each individual soil. When optimized, the SHM reproduced the partitioning of Cd, Cu and Zn but not Pb. It was necessary to revise the affinity constants for the NDM to simultaneously simulate the partitioning of the four metals. Revised affinity constants for the NDM model based on a fixed definition of soil organic carbon, i.e., a fixed ratio of fulvic and humic acids per unit carbon, reproduced metal partitioning more effectively in an independent data set of 16 soils than the use of generic affinity constants available for these models. From the perspective of the applicability of these models to risk assessment, this result suggests geochemical models using affinity constants that have been verified and/or modified against multiple soils from a region can provide good estimates of metal partitioning on a regional scale.
痕量金属(TM)的迁移性和毒性会随土壤条件的变化而改变。地球化学模型可以解释土壤特性对痕量金属行为的影响。我们测试了斯德哥尔摩腐殖质模型(SHM)和NICA-Donnan模型(NDM)在估算26个灰化土森林地表层中分配系数(logKd)方面的有效性,这些灰化土因金属冶炼厂的沉积物而富含痕量金属。我们想知道是否可以应用一种一致的方法来模拟森林地表层中的金属分配,而无需对每种土壤进行单独优化。经过优化后,SHM能够重现镉、铜和锌的分配情况,但无法重现铅的分配情况。有必要修订NDM的亲和常数,以便同时模拟这四种金属的分配。基于土壤有机碳的固定定义(即每单位碳中富里酸和腐殖酸的固定比例)对NDM模型进行修订后的亲和常数,在一个包含16种土壤的独立数据集中,比使用这些模型可用的通用亲和常数更有效地重现了金属分配情况。从这些模型在风险评估中的适用性角度来看,这一结果表明,使用针对某一区域多种土壤进行验证和/或修正的亲和常数的地球化学模型,可以在区域尺度上对金属分配情况做出良好的估计。