Li Ai-wu, Zhang Wen-tong, Li Fu-hai, Cui Xin-hai, Duan Xiang-sheng
Department of Paediatric Surgery, Qilu Hospital, Shandong University, Ji'nan 250012, China.
Chin Med J (Engl). 2006 Jan 5;119(1):37-42.
One stage transanal Soave pull-through procedure (TSPP) is a recent popular operation in the treatment of Hirschsprung's disease (HD). With no visible scar and a short hospital stay, it is well accepted by surgeons and mothers. In the conventional Soave procedure, a long rectal muscular cuff left for anocolic anastomosis might increase the incidence of postoperative enterocolitis and constipation. This study presents a modified transanal Soave pull-through procedure (MTSPP) which includes an oblique mucosectomy and an oblique anastomosis with a short split muscular cuff.
A review of two groups of HD patients was made: 112 underwent conventional transanal Soave procedure from 1999 to 2001 (group 1) and 140 underwent modified transanal Soave procedure from 2002 to 2004 (group 2). A comparison was made between the two groups on operative data and postoperative complications. The data included: age at the operation, operating time, blood loss, time to feeds and hospital stay, occurrence of postoperative enterocolitis or constipation, need for anal dilatation, postoperative bowel function and perianal skin problems.
There was no significant difference between two groups with respect to age, gender, length of colon resected, operating time, blood loss and hospital stay. However occurrence of postoperative enterocolitis, constipation, anastomotic stricture and time needed for anal dilatation were evidently less in group 2 (MTSPP). The mean operating time in group 1 was (106 +/- 39) minutes with a range of 60 to 170 minutes; in group 2 was (101 +/- 36) minutes with a range of 66 to 190 minutes. The average length of the bowel resected in group 1 was (24 +/- 7) cm, range 15 to 58 cm; in group 2 was (26 +/- 8) cm, range 15 to 70 cm. Two patients, one in each group, required laparoscopic assistance because of long aganglionic colon. Another patient in group 2 required laparotomy because of total colonic aganglionosis. Postoperative complications in group 1 included: temporary perianal excoriation in 34 patients (26 were < 3 months of age), enterocolitis in 21, anastomotic stricture in 11, recurrent constipation in 12, cuff abscess in 1, anastomosis leak in 1, soiling in 3 and rectal prolapse in 1. In group 2 post operative complications included: transient perianal excoriation in 37 patients (30 were < 3 months of age), enterocolitis in 13, anastomotic stricture in 5, recurrent constipation in 6, anastomotic leak in 1, adhesive bowel obstruction in 1 and soiling in 4. Complete bowel continence was found in 97 children (86.6%) in group 1 and in 129 children (92.1%) in group 2 at one year followup after operation.
Modified transanal Soave pull-through procedure for HD with oblique mucosectomy and anastomosis and a short split muscular cuff is a safe and feasible operation with low incidence of postoperative complication. It is an encouraging improvement of the conventional transanal Soave pull-through procedure. MTSPP is a preferable choice in the surgery of HD.
一期经肛门Soave拖出术(TSPP)是近年来治疗先天性巨结肠(HD)常用的手术方式。该术式无明显瘢痕且住院时间短,受到外科医生和患儿家长的广泛认可。在传统的Soave手术中,保留较长的直肠肌鞘用于肛管结肠吻合可能会增加术后小肠结肠炎和便秘的发生率。本研究提出一种改良的经肛门Soave拖出术(MTSPP),包括斜行黏膜切除术和带短肌鞘劈开的斜行吻合术。
回顾性分析两组HD患者:1999年至2001年112例行传统经肛门Soave手术(第1组),2002年至2004年140例行改良经肛门Soave手术(第2组)。比较两组患者的手术数据和术后并发症。数据包括:手术年龄、手术时间、出血量、开始进食时间、住院时间、术后小肠结肠炎或便秘的发生率、扩肛需求、术后肠道功能及肛周皮肤问题。
两组患者在年龄、性别、结肠切除长度、手术时间、出血量和住院时间方面无显著差异。然而,第2组(MTSPP)术后小肠结肠炎、便秘、吻合口狭窄及扩肛所需时间明显较少。第1组平均手术时间为(106±39)分钟,范围为60至170分钟;第2组为(101±36)分钟,范围为66至190分钟。第1组平均切除肠段长度为(24±7)cm,范围为15至58 cm;第2组为(26±8)cm,范围为15至70 cm。两组各有1例患者因无神经节段结肠过长需腹腔镜辅助。第2组另1例患者因全结肠无神经节症需剖腹手术。第1组术后并发症包括:34例患者出现暂时性肛周皮肤糜烂(26例年龄小于3个月),21例发生小肠结肠炎,11例出现吻合口狭窄,12例反复便秘,1例肌鞘脓肿,1例吻合口漏,3例大便污染,1例直肠脱垂。第2组术后并发症包括:37例患者出现暂时性肛周皮肤糜烂(30例年龄小于3个月),13例发生小肠结肠炎,5例出现吻合口狭窄,6例反复便秘,1例吻合口漏,1例粘连性肠梗阻,4例大便污染。术后1年随访时,第1组97例患儿(86.6%)、第2组129例患儿(92.1%)实现完全控便。
改良经肛门Soave拖出术采用斜行黏膜切除、吻合及短肌鞘劈开治疗HD,是一种安全可行的手术方式,术后并发症发生率低。是对传统经肛门Soave拖出术令人鼓舞的改进。MTSPP是HD手术中更优的选择。