Davidson Jonathan R T, Connor Kathryn M, Swartz Marvin
Department of Psychiatry, Duke University Medical Center, Durham, North Carolina 27710, USA.
J Nerv Ment Dis. 2006 Jan;194(1):47-51. doi: 10.1097/01.nmd.0000195309.17887.f5.
Numerous historical accounts suggest the presence of mental illness in US Presidents, but no systematic review has been undertaken for all holders of this office. We reviewed biographical sources regarding mental illness in 37 US Presidents from 1776 to 1974. Material was extracted by one of the authors and given to experienced psychiatrists for independent review of the correspondence of behaviors, symptoms, and medical information in source material to DSM-IV criteria for Axis I disorders. Levels of confidence were given for each diagnosis. Eighteen (49%) Presidents met criteria suggesting psychiatric disorder: depression (24%), anxiety (8%), bipolar disorder (8%), and alcohol abuse/dependence (8%) were the most common. In 10 instances (27%), a disorder was evident during presidential office, which in most cases probably impaired job performance. Mental illness in heads of state is a topic deserving further attention. Methodological limitations of using biography to determine psychopathology are discussed.
众多历史记载表明美国总统中存在精神疾病,但尚未对历任总统进行过系统的综述。我们查阅了1776年至1974年间37位美国总统有关精神疾病的传记资料。由一位作者提取资料,并交给经验丰富的精神科医生,依据《精神疾病诊断与统计手册》第四版(DSM-IV)中轴I障碍的标准,对资料中行为、症状及医学信息的对应关系进行独立评估。对每个诊断给出了置信水平。18位(49%)总统符合精神疾病诊断标准:抑郁症(24%)、焦虑症(8%)、双相情感障碍(8%)以及酒精滥用/依赖(8%)最为常见。在10例(27%)中,在总统任期内疾病明显,多数情况下可能损害了工作表现。国家元首的精神疾病是一个值得进一步关注的话题。本文讨论了利用传记确定精神病理学的方法学局限性。