Bennett C M, McKendry I G, Kelly S, Denike K, Koch T
Department of Epidemiology and Preventive Medicine, Monash University, Central and Eastern Clinical School, The Alfred Hospital, Commercial Road, Melbourne, VIC 3004, Australia.
Sci Total Environ. 2006 Aug 1;366(2-3):918-25. doi: 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2005.12.025. Epub 2006 Feb 17.
The adverse public health impacts of anthropogenically derived particulate matter have been well documented, with measurable increases in both morbidity and mortality rates associated with high particulate matter pollution events. Most current research has focussed on the health impacts of anthropogenically derived particulate matter, and there is a distinct scarcity of literature that examines the role of naturally derived particulate matter and adverse health impacts in the urban context. This study of a Gobi desert dust event in the Greater Vancouver region of British Columbia, Canada, in spring of 1998 provided a unique opportunity to identify the adverse health effects related to naturally derived particulate matter in a large urban setting. Respiratory and cardiac hospitalizations were examined for a three-year period (January 1997 to December 1999), with the Gobi dust event occurring in late April 1998. A meteorological analogue was identified for spring 1997 in order to identify the public health impacts associated with anthropogenically derived particulate matter and those impacts associated with the presence of the Gobi desert dust. Results indicate that this Gobi dust event was not associated with an excess of hospitalizations in the Greater Vancouver region. Peak particulate matter concentrations of Gobi desert dust in the airshed were only associated with an additional one or two hospitalizations per 100,000 population for respiratory and cardiac illnesses, and these increases were not distinguishable from the 'normal' variability in hospitalization rates. Despite high particulate matter concentrations, fine particle size, presence of heavy metals in the dust and extended exposure periods, it appears that the Gobi desert dust event was not associated with significant risk to public health in Greater Vancouver, British Columbia. Therefore it is concluded that naturally derived particulate matter is more benign than particulate matter of anthropogenic origin, and thus poses a low risk to health for the general public.
人为来源的颗粒物对公众健康的不利影响已有充分记录,在高颗粒物污染事件中,发病率和死亡率都有可测量的增加。目前大多数研究都集中在人为来源颗粒物对健康的影响上,而专门研究自然来源颗粒物在城市环境中的作用及其对健康的不利影响的文献明显匮乏。1998年春季对加拿大不列颠哥伦比亚省大温哥华地区的一次戈壁沙漠沙尘事件进行的这项研究,提供了一个独特的机会,来确定在一个大型城市环境中与自然来源颗粒物相关的不利健康影响。对1997年1月至1999年12月这三年期间的呼吸道和心脏疾病住院情况进行了调查,戈壁沙尘事件发生在1998年4月下旬。确定了1997年春季的一个气象类似情况,以便确定与人为来源颗粒物相关的公共卫生影响以及与戈壁沙漠沙尘存在相关的影响。结果表明,这次戈壁沙尘事件与大温哥华地区住院人数的增加无关。该地区空气中戈壁沙漠沙尘的颗粒物浓度峰值,仅与每10万人口中因呼吸道和心脏疾病额外增加一到两次住院情况相关,而且这些增加与住院率的“正常”波动无法区分。尽管颗粒物浓度高、颗粒细小、沙尘中存在重金属且暴露时间延长,但看来戈壁沙漠沙尘事件与不列颠哥伦比亚省大温哥华地区的公众健康重大风险并无关联。因此得出结论,自然来源的颗粒物比人为来源的颗粒物危害更小,因此对公众健康构成的风险较低。