Fowler Kimberly, Poehling Katherine, Billheimer Dean, Hamilton Rodney, Wu Huiyun, Mulder John, Frangoul Haydar
Department of Hematology Oncology, University of Alabama, Birmingham, AL, USA.
J Clin Oncol. 2006 Mar 1;24(7):1099-104. doi: 10.1200/JCO.2005.02.6591.
To examine hospice referral patterns among pediatric oncologists and identify barriers to referral.
A self-administered survey was sent to 1,200 pediatric oncologists who are members of Children's Oncology Group. Two electronic mail messages followed by traditional mail surveys were sent to eligible physicians. Pediatricians and pediatric oncologists developed, pretested, and modified the survey for item clarification.
Of 944 eligible pediatric oncologists surveyed, 632 replied, yielding a response rate of 67%. Most respondents reported having access to palliative care programs (65%) and hospice services (85%), but few (27%) had access to inpatient hospice services. More respondents reported feeling comfortable managing end-of-life pain than psychological issues (86% v 67%, respectively). Many pediatric oncologists (62%) reported that half or more of their patients died in the hospital. In multivariate analysis, physicians with access to hospice that accepts patients receiving chemotherapy had more patients die at home than in hospital compared with physicians without access to such services (P = .007). The probability of hospice referral was positively associated with the presence of a hospice facility (P < .001) and with a larger size oncology group (P = .024). Only 2.5% of respondents referred patients at the time of relapse. Continued therapy was cited as the most common reason for not making a referral, and was significantly higher when hospice did not admit children receiving chemotherapy (P = .002).
Hospice referral for children with cancer is usually made late in the course of their disease and might improve if hospice admits patients who are actively receiving chemotherapy.
研究儿科肿瘤学家的临终关怀转诊模式,并确定转诊障碍。
向1200名儿童肿瘤学组的成员儿科肿瘤学家发送了一份自填式调查问卷。先发送了两封电子邮件,随后进行传统邮件调查,发给符合条件的医生。儿科医生和儿科肿瘤学家共同制定、预测试并修改了调查问卷以澄清项目。
在944名接受调查的符合条件的儿科肿瘤学家中,632人回复,回复率为67%。大多数受访者报告可以获得姑息治疗项目(65%)和临终关怀服务(85%),但很少有人(27%)可以获得住院临终关怀服务。更多受访者表示在处理临终疼痛方面比心理问题更得心应手(分别为86%对67%)。许多儿科肿瘤学家(62%)报告说,他们一半或更多的患者在医院死亡。在多变量分析中,与无法获得此类服务的医生相比,能够获得接受化疗患者的临终关怀服务的医生,其患者在家中死亡的比例高于在医院死亡的比例(P = 0.007)。临终关怀转诊的可能性与存在临终关怀机构呈正相关(P < 0.001),与规模较大的肿瘤学组呈正相关(P = 0.024)。只有2.5%的受访者在患者复发时转诊。继续治疗被认为是不进行转诊的最常见原因,当临终关怀机构不收治接受化疗的儿童时,这一比例显著更高(P = 0.002)。
癌症患儿的临终关怀转诊通常在疾病过程的后期进行,如果临终关怀机构收治正在积极接受化疗的患者,转诊情况可能会有所改善。