Sponseller Paul D, Jones Kevin B, Ahn Nicholas U, Erkula Gurkan, Foran Jared R H, Dietz Harry C
Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Johns Hopkins Medical Institutions, Johns Hopkins Outpatient Center, 5th Floor, 601 North Caroline Street, Baltimore, MD 21287, USA.
J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2006 Mar;88(3):486-95. doi: 10.2106/JBJS.E.00611.
Protrusio acetabuli is known to occur in patients with Marfan syndrome, but its prevalence, its effects on hip function, and its possible association with the subsequent development of degenerative hip disease have not been studied in a large population. Nevertheless, some clinicians have recommended prophylactic hip surgery for preadolescents with Marfan syndrome and protrusio acetabuli.
We performed a cross-sectional study of 173 patients (346 hips) with Marfan syndrome who were interviewed and examined for calculation of the Iowa hip score. Anteroposterior radiographs of the pelvis were made, and two radiographic indices of acetabular depth were measured: (1) the center-edge angle of Wiberg and (2) the acetabular-ilioischial distance. The presence of protrusio was defined with use of two extant definitions: (1) a center-edge angle of >50 degrees or (2) an acetabular-ilioischial distance of >/=3 mm in male patients or >/=6 mm in female patients. Linear regression analyses were performed between these radiographic indices of acetabular depth and patient age, Iowa hip scores, the magnitude of the radiographic joint space, and range of motion.
The prevalence of protrusio acetabuli was 27% according to the center-edge angle criterion and 16% according to the acetabular-ilioischial distance criterion. The prevalence of protrusio increased until the age of twenty years and remained stable after the age of twenty years. Slight but significant negative correlations were detected between the two radiographic indices of acetabular depth and both the Iowa hip score and the summed range of motion (p < 0.02 for all). No significant relationship was found between the two radiographic indices and pain scores. In patients with Marfan syndrome who were more than forty years old, the Iowa hip scores for hips with protrusio were not significantly lower than those for hips without protrusio.
In patients with Marfan syndrome, the prevalence of protrusio acetabuli increases during the first two decades of life and then plateaus in terms of both population-wide prevalence and radiographic severity. In this population, protrusio generally is not associated with severely problematic hip function but it is associated with slightly decreased range of motion of the hip. We concluded that prophylactic surgical intervention is not indicated for most patients with Marfan syndrome who have a radiographic diagnosis of protrusio.
已知马方综合征患者会出现髋臼前突,但在大量人群中尚未对其患病率、对髋关节功能的影响以及与退行性髋部疾病后续发展的可能关联进行研究。然而,一些临床医生已建议对患有马方综合征和髋臼前突的青春期前儿童进行预防性髋关节手术。
我们对173例马方综合征患者(346个髋关节)进行了横断面研究,对他们进行访谈并检查以计算爱荷华髋关节评分。拍摄骨盆前后位X线片,并测量髋臼深度的两个影像学指标:(1)Wiberg中心边缘角;(2)髋臼-髂坐骨距离。根据两种现有定义确定髋臼前突的存在:(1)中心边缘角>50度;(2)男性患者髋臼-髂坐骨距离> /= 3 mm,女性患者> /= 6 mm。对这些髋臼深度的影像学指标与患者年龄、爱荷华髋关节评分、影像学关节间隙大小和活动范围进行线性回归分析。
根据中心边缘角标准,髋臼前突的患病率为27%,根据髋臼-髂坐骨距离标准为16%。髋臼前突的患病率在20岁之前上升,20岁之后保持稳定。在髋臼深度的两个影像学指标与爱荷华髋关节评分和总活动范围之间检测到轻微但显著的负相关(所有p < 0.02)。在两个影像学指标与疼痛评分之间未发现显著关系。在年龄超过40岁的马方综合征患者中,有髋臼前突的髋关节的爱荷华髋关节评分并不显著低于无髋臼前突的髋关节。
在马方综合征患者中,髋臼前突的患病率在生命的前二十年中增加,然后在人群患病率和影像学严重程度方面趋于平稳。在该人群中,髋臼前突通常与严重的髋关节功能问题无关,但与髋关节活动范围略有减小有关。我们得出结论,对于大多数经影像学诊断为髋臼前突的马方综合征患者,不建议进行预防性手术干预。