Qin Baoli, Tanaka Risa, Shibata Yoshihiro, Arita Shuji, Ariyama Hiroshi, Kusaba Hitoshi, Baba Eishi, Harada Mine, Nakano Shuji
First Department of Internal Medicine and Department of Biosystemic Science of Medicine, Graduate School of Medicine, Kyushu University, Fukuoka, Japan.
Anticancer Drugs. 2006 Apr;17(4):445-53. doi: 10.1097/01.cad.0000198912.98442.cd.
In order to define the most effective combination schedule of oxaliplatin (L-OHP) and 5-fluorouracil (5-FU), we investigated the in vitro interaction between these drugs in a panel of four human gastric adenocarcinoma cell lines (MKN-1, NUGC-3, NUGC-5 and AZ-521). Cytotoxic activity was determined by the WST-1 assay. Different schedules of the two drugs were compared and evaluated for synergism, additivity or antagonism with a quantitative method based on the median-effect principle of Chou and Talalay. Cell cycle perturbation and apoptosis were evaluated by flow cytometry. Simultaneous and sequential treatments of L-OHP followed by 5-FU exhibited synergistic effects in all four cell lines, whereas the reverse sequence yielded a clear antagonism. 5-FU exclusively arrested cells at the G0/G1 phase, and L-OHP at the G0/G1 and G2/M phases. Apoptosis was most prominent when cells were treated simultaneously or in a sequence of L-OHP followed by 5-FU, producing apoptosis in the majority of treated cells (55.5-61.5%). In contrast, the reverse sequence yielded only 20% induction of apoptosis, the rate being not significantly different from those induced by each drug singly. Moreover, this sequence dependence was further confirmed by the experiment which compared the total number of NUGC-3 cells 7 days after these combination schedules. These findings suggest that the interaction of 5-FU and L-OHP could be highly schedule dependent, with the most efficacious interaction observed in simultaneous combination and that 5-FU followed by L-OHP would not be recommended in clinical trials for patients with advanced gastric cancer.
为了确定奥沙利铂(L-OHP)与5-氟尿嘧啶(5-FU)最有效的联合用药方案,我们在四种人胃腺癌细胞系(MKN-1、NUGC-3、NUGC-5和AZ-521)中研究了这两种药物的体外相互作用。通过WST-1法测定细胞毒性活性。采用基于Chou和Talalay中值效应原理的定量方法,比较和评估了两种药物的不同给药方案的协同、相加或拮抗作用。通过流式细胞术评估细胞周期扰动和凋亡情况。L-OHP后接5-FU的同时给药和序贯给药在所有四种细胞系中均表现出协同作用,而相反的顺序则产生明显的拮抗作用。5-FU单独使细胞停滞在G0/G1期,L-OHP使细胞停滞在G0/G1期和G2/M期。当细胞同时或按L-OHP后接5-FU的顺序处理时,凋亡最为显著,大多数处理细胞(55.5-61.5%)发生凋亡。相比之下,相反的顺序仅诱导20%的凋亡,该比率与每种药物单独诱导的凋亡率无显著差异。此外,通过比较这些联合用药方案7天后NUGC-3细胞总数的实验进一步证实了这种顺序依赖性。这些发现表明,5-FU与L-OHP的相互作用可能高度依赖给药顺序,同时联合用药时观察到最有效的相互作用,并且在晚期胃癌患者的临床试验中不推荐5-FU后接L-OHP的用药顺序。