Perearnau P, Vuillemet F, Schick J, Weill G
Service Médical de l'Assurance maladie de Colmar, CNAMTS.
Rev Neurol (Paris). 2006 Mar;162(3):347-57. doi: 10.1016/s0035-3787(06)75021-4.
AIMS: To analyze use of triptans in the Alsace region of France: patients, disorders motivating, doses, analgesics and migraine prophylactics associated treatments, contra-indications. To study major consumers (more than 144 intakes per year) and to determine among them the proportion who suffering from chronic headache. METHOD: Data concerning all prescriptions of triptans and analgesics as well as migraine prophylaxis prescriptions were obtained from the computer databases of five of the French National Health's local health agencies in Alsace, recorded between April 1, 2003 and March 31, 2004. Data about motivating disorders and the clinical context were obtained using a questionnaire sent to prescribers. Data about patients with more than 144 intakes per year were provided by medical advisors of French Health insurance. RESULTS: We founded 20686 users: 92.1 percent used between 0 and 6 intakes per month. 11.5 percent of disorders motivating the prescription that were mentioned by prescribers were for off-label use: tension-type headache 2.7 percent, mixed headache, 8.8 percent. Prescribers declared at least one contra-indication for triptan use for 7.8 percent of patients. Over all, prescriptions were off-label for 16.1 percent of patients. Patients who used more than 144 intakes per year accounted for 1.9 percent of the total number and self-medication accounted for 19.2 percent of all triptan intakes. Half of the patients were suffering from daily chronic headache (chronic migraine in 66 percent). 15.6 percent of these patients presented at least one contraindication (high blood pressure or ischemic disease). All in all we estimate that use of triptan is a misuse for 25 percent to 30 percent of the intakes. Quantities of other analgesics used increased simultaneously with triptan use: on average 65, 119 and 244 Defined Daily Doses (DDD)/person/year for patients who used between 1 and 72, 73 and 144 and more than 144 intakes respectively. On average 35.4 percent (in DDD) of analgesics used were opiates (dextropropoxyphene, codeine, tramadol). This proportion increased simultaneously with triptan use: 58.9 percent for major users. Prophylactic treatment for migraine was used by 27.9 percent of the patients: lack of prophylaxis was a prescriber's choice in 90 percent of the cases. CONCLUSIONS: The high rate of triptan misuse emphasizes the importance of improving prescription of these drugs.
目的:分析法国阿尔萨斯地区曲坦类药物的使用情况:患者、用药动机、剂量、联用的镇痛药和偏头痛预防性治疗药物、禁忌证。研究主要使用者(每年用药超过144次),并确定其中慢性头痛患者的比例。 方法:获取2003年4月1日至2004年3月31日期间法国国家卫生署在阿尔萨斯地区的5个地方卫生机构计算机数据库中有关曲坦类药物和镇痛药的所有处方以及偏头痛预防性治疗处方的数据。通过向开处方者发送问卷获取有关用药动机疾病和临床背景的数据。法国健康保险的医学顾问提供了每年用药超过144次的患者的数据。 结果:我们发现了20686名使用者:92.1%的使用者每月用药0至6次。开处方者提到的用于非适应证用药的用药动机疾病占11.5%:紧张型头痛占2.7%,混合型头痛占8.8%。开处方者声明7.8%的患者至少有一项曲坦类药物使用的禁忌证。总体而言,16.1%的患者存在非适应证用药情况。每年用药超过144次的患者占总数的1.9%,自我用药占所有曲坦类药物用药量的19.2%。一半的患者患有每日慢性头痛(66%为慢性偏头痛)。这些患者中有15.6%至少有一项禁忌证(高血压或缺血性疾病)。总体而言,我们估计25%至30%的曲坦类药物用药属于滥用。随着曲坦类药物使用量的增加,其他镇痛药的使用量也同时增加:每年用药1至72次、73至144次以及超过144次的患者,平均每人每年分别使用65、119和244限定日剂量(DDD)的镇痛药。平均35.4%(以DDD计)的镇痛药使用为阿片类药物(右丙氧芬、可待因、曲马多);这一比例随着曲坦类药物使用量的增加而同时上升:主要使用者中这一比例为58.9%。27.9%的患者使用了偏头痛预防性治疗药物:在90%的情况下,未进行预防性治疗是开处方者的选择结果。 结论:曲坦类药物的高滥用率凸显了改善这些药物处方的重要性。
Rev Neurol (Paris). 2006-3
Curr Med Res Opin. 2002
J Manag Care Spec Pharm. 2014-4
PLoS One. 2013-12-19
Eur J Clin Pharmacol. 2009-12-19
J Headache Pain. 2008-4