Gauden Piotr A, Terzyk Artur P, Kowalczyk Piotr
Department of Chemistry, N. Copernicus University, Physicochemistry of Carbon Materials Research Group, Gagarina 7, 87-100 Torun, Poland.
J Colloid Interface Sci. 2006 Aug 15;300(2):453-74. doi: 10.1016/j.jcis.2006.04.017. Epub 2006 Apr 7.
Different authors investigated the effects of geometric and energetic heterogeneities on adsorption and on carbon characterization methods. In most theoretical studies carbon structure is modeled as parallel infinite graphite walls that form ideal slit-shaped pores of the fixed widths. In the literature there is the lack of systematic studies showing the influence of pore structural and Lennard-Jones (LJ) potential parameters on the pore-size distribution functions. Moreover, the parameters characterizing the properties of the adsorbed phase and the heterogeneity of the adsorbent surface should be taken into account. The Nguyen and Do method with proposed by us ASA algorithm, were utilized for the assessment of the porosity from the series of almost few thousands numerically generated local adsorption isotherms. The values of the mentioned-above parameters are varied over the wide range (ca. +/-20%) of the reference ones. Different types of the theoretical and experimental adsorption isotherms (nitrogen at 77 K) were taken into account as the global ones. They were related to the mechanism of the primary, secondary or mixed micropore filling. The variations in some above-mentioned parameters have significant effects only for PSDs (and for average pore widths) corresponding to the primary micropore filling mechanism. On the other hand, for the process of the secondary micropore filling, the influence of these parameters (without the BET coefficient for adsorption on a "flat" surface, c(s,B)) is rather insignificant. Nevertheless the differences between local and global adsorption isotherms (in the whole range of relative pressures) the absence of micropores having pore half width equal to ca. 1 nm on PSDs was observed for studied adsorbate-adsorbent systems with exceptions of the strictly microporous adsorbents and/or the low values of c(s,B). Comparison of the experimental data with the generated theoretical isosteric enthalpy of adsorption indicates that the phenomenal uptake observed from experiment can be explained in terms of the reasonable solid-fluid interaction parameters. Therefore, we varied the heterogeneity of the adsorbent surface via the strength and the range of the solid-fluid potential and the parameter c(s,B) in order to reproduce the experimental data of enthalpy of adsorption. Note that similar procedure was applied by Wang and Johnson to reproduce some hydrogen adsorption data measured for carbon nanofibres. The analysis of the obtained results shows that the selection of the values of the parameters of the intermolecular interactions and the quantities characterizing the properties of the adsorbed phase and the heterogeneity of the adsorbent walls for molecular simulations should be made with care and the influence of possible errors should be considered.
不同的作者研究了几何和能量非均质性对吸附以及碳表征方法的影响。在大多数理论研究中,碳结构被建模为平行的无限石墨壁,这些石墨壁形成了固定宽度的理想狭缝形孔隙。文献中缺乏系统的研究来表明孔隙结构和 Lennard-Jones(LJ)势参数对孔径分布函数的影响。此外,还应考虑表征吸附相性质和吸附剂表面非均质性的参数。我们提出的 Nguyen 和 Do 方法以及 ASA 算法,被用于从一系列近数千个数值生成的局部吸附等温线来评估孔隙率。上述参数的值在参考值的很宽范围内(约±20%)变化。考虑了不同类型的理论和实验吸附等温线(77 K 下的氮气)作为全局等温线。它们与初级、次级或混合微孔填充机制相关。上述一些参数的变化仅对对应于初级微孔填充机制的孔径分布(以及平均孔径)有显著影响。另一方面,对于次级微孔填充过程,这些参数(不包括在“平坦”表面上吸附的 BET 系数 c(s,B))的影响相当小。然而,在所研究的吸附质 - 吸附剂体系中,除了严格的微孔吸附剂和/或 c(s,B) 值较低的情况外,在孔径分布上观察到局部和全局吸附等温线之间的差异(在整个相对压力范围内),即不存在孔径半宽约为 1 nm 的微孔。将实验数据与生成的理论等量吸附热进行比较表明,实验中观察到的显著吸附量可以用合理的固 - 液相互作用参数来解释。因此,我们通过固 - 液势的强度和范围以及参数 c(s,B) 来改变吸附剂表面的非均质性,以便重现吸附热的实验数据。请注意,Wang 和 Johnson 采用了类似的程序来重现一些针对碳纳米纤维测量的氢吸附数据。对所得结果的分析表明,在分子模拟中,分子间相互作用参数以及表征吸附相性质和吸附剂壁非均质性的量值的选择应谨慎,并应考虑可能误差的影响。