Muirhead David, Harvey Carol, Ingram Graham
North-west Area Mental Health Services, Coburg, Victoria, Australia.
Aust N Z J Psychiatry. 2006 Jun-Jul;40(6-7):596-605. doi: 10.1080/j.1440-1614.2006.01844.x.
This study examined the effectiveness of community treatment orders (CTOs) used in the treatment of patients with schizophrenia. The hypotheses were that CTOs enhance outcome for patients whose mental health would otherwise be compromised by poor adherence with treatment and that CTOs would enable this when either oral or depot antipsychotic medication was prescribed.
This was a naturalistic study using a retrospective mirror-image design. The sample consisted of patients with schizophrenia (n = 94) who were treated on a CTO between November 1996 and October 1999. Two subgroups were defined: patients treated with oral antipsychotic medication (n = 31), and patients treated with depot medication (n = 63). Data were gathered via file review using a questionnaire.
For the whole sample and both subgroups the findings included significant increased number of service contacts, decreased number of admissions and decreased length of inpatient stay. For the total sample numbers of crisis team referrals and other episodes of relapse were significantly decreased. For the subgroup on depot medication there was a non-significant trend towards fewer crisis team referrals and a significant decrease in other episodes of relapse. There were no significant differences for the oral subgroup in crisis team referrals or other episodes of relapse.
This study provides further evidence that CTOs may be effective in improving the outcome for selected persons with schizophrenia and some evidence that they may enhance the outcome for selected patients with schizophrenia on oral antipsychotic medication.
本研究探讨社区治疗令(CTO)用于治疗精神分裂症患者的有效性。研究假设为,CTO可改善那些因治疗依从性差而心理健康会受到损害的患者的治疗效果,且无论开具的是口服还是长效抗精神病药物,CTO均能实现这一效果。
这是一项采用回顾性镜像设计的自然主义研究。样本包括1996年11月至1999年10月期间接受CTO治疗的精神分裂症患者(n = 94)。定义了两个亚组:接受口服抗精神病药物治疗的患者(n = 31)和接受长效药物治疗的患者(n = 63)。通过使用问卷进行档案审查收集数据。
对于整个样本以及两个亚组,研究结果包括服务接触次数显著增加、住院次数减少以及住院时间缩短。对于整个样本,危机干预小组转诊次数和其他复发事件的数量显著减少。对于接受长效药物治疗的亚组,危机干预小组转诊次数有减少的非显著趋势,其他复发事件显著减少。接受口服药物治疗的亚组在危机干预小组转诊次数或其他复发事件方面无显著差异。
本研究进一步证明CTO可能对部分精神分裂症患者改善治疗效果有效,并有一些证据表明CTO可能提高部分接受口服抗精神病药物治疗的精神分裂症患者的治疗效果。