Hong Rathavuth, Montana Livia, Mishra Vinod
Demographic and Health Research Division, ORC Macro, 11785 Beltsville Drive, Calverton, MD 20705, USA.
BMC Health Serv Res. 2006 Jun 22;6:79. doi: 10.1186/1472-6963-6-79.
Both availability and quality of family planning services are believed to have contributed to increasing contraceptive use and declining fertility rates in developing countries. Yet, there is limited empirical evidence to show the relationship between the quality of family planning services and the population based prevalence of contraceptive methods. This study examined the relationship between quality of family planning services and use of intrauterine devices (IUD) in Egypt.
The analysis used data from the 2003 Egypt Interim Demographic and Health Survey (EIDHS) that included 8,445 married women aged 15-49, and the 2002 Egypt Service Provision Assessment (ESPA) survey that included 602 facilities offering family planning services. The EIDHS collected latitude and longitude coordinates of all sampled clusters, and the ESPA collected these coordinates for all sampled facilities. Using Geographic Information System (GIS) methods, individual women were linked to a facility located within 10 km of their community. A facility-level index was constructed to reflect the quality of family planning services. Four dimensions of quality of care were examined: counseling, examination room, supply of contraceptive methods, and management. Effects of quality of family planning services on the use of IUD and other contraceptive methods were estimated using multinomial logistic regression. Results are presented as relative risk ratios (RRR) with significance levels (p-values).
IUD use among women who obtained their method from public sources was significantly positively associated with quality of family planning services (RRR = 1.36, p < 0.01), independent of distance to the facility, facility type, age, number of living children, education level, household wealth status, and residence. Quality of services related to counseling and examination room had strong positive effects on use of IUD (RRR = 1.61 for counseling and RRR = 1.46 for examination room). Obtaining IUD from a private source or using other contraceptive methods was not associated with quality of services.
This study is one among the few that used geographic information to link data from a population-based survey with an independently sampled health facility survey. The findings demonstrate that service quality is an important determinant of use of clinical contraceptive methods in Egypt. Improving quality of family planning services may help further increase use of clinical contraceptive methods and reduce fertility.
人们认为计划生育服务的可及性和质量都促使发展中国家避孕药具的使用增加,生育率下降。然而,仅有有限的实证证据表明计划生育服务质量与基于人群的避孕方法普及率之间的关系。本研究调查了埃及计划生育服务质量与宫内节育器(IUD)使用之间的关系。
分析使用了2003年埃及临时人口与健康调查(EIDHS)的数据,该调查涵盖了8445名年龄在15至49岁的已婚妇女,以及2002年埃及服务提供评估(ESPA)调查的数据,该调查涵盖了602个提供计划生育服务的机构。EIDHS收集了所有抽样群组的纬度和经度坐标,ESPA收集了所有抽样机构的这些坐标。使用地理信息系统(GIS)方法,将个体妇女与距离其社区10公里内的一个机构相联系。构建了一个机构层面的指数来反映计划生育服务的质量。考察了护理质量的四个维度:咨询、检查室、避孕药具供应和管理。使用多项逻辑回归估计计划生育服务质量对IUD及其他避孕方法使用的影响。结果以相对风险比(RRR)和显著性水平(p值)呈现。
从公共渠道获取避孕方法的妇女中IUD的使用与计划生育服务质量显著正相关(RRR = 1.36,p < 0.01),不受距离机构远近、机构类型、年龄、存活子女数、教育水平、家庭财富状况和居住地的影响。与咨询和检查室相关的服务质量对IUD的使用有强烈的积极影响(咨询的RRR = 1.61,检查室的RRR = 1.46)。从私人渠道获取IUD或使用其他避孕方法与服务质量无关。
本研究是少数使用地理信息将基于人群的调查数据与独立抽样的卫生机构调查数据相联系的研究之一。研究结果表明,服务质量是埃及临床避孕方法使用的一个重要决定因素。提高计划生育服务质量可能有助于进一步增加临床避孕方法的使用并降低生育率。