Smith T M, Olejniczak A J, Reid D J, Ferrell R J, Hublin J J
Human Evolution Department, Max Planck Institute for Evolutionary Anthropology, Deutscher Platz 6, D-04103 Leipzig, Germany.
Arch Oral Biol. 2006 Nov;51(11):974-95. doi: 10.1016/j.archoralbio.2006.04.012. Epub 2006 Jun 30.
This study examines cross-sections of molar crowns in a diverse modern human sample to quantify variation in enamel thickness and enamel-dentine junction (EDJ) shape. Histological sections were generated from molars sectioned buccolingually across mesial cusps. Enamel cap area, dentine area, EDJ length, and bi-cervical diameter were measured on micrographs using a digitizing tablet. Nine landmarks along the EDJ were defined, and X and Y coordinates were digitized in order to quantify EDJ shape. Upper molars show greater values for the components of enamel thickness, leading to significantly greater average enamel thickness than in lower molars. Average enamel thickness increased significantly from M1 to M3 in both molar rows, due to significantly increasing enamel cap area in upper molars, and decreasing dentine area in lower molars. Differences in EDJ shape were found among maxillary molars in combined and individual populations. Sex differences were also found; males showed significantly greater dentine area, EDJ length, and bi-cervical diameters in certain tooth types, which resulted in females having significantly thicker average enamel. Differences in enamel thickness and EDJ shape within molars were also found among populations, although few consistent trends were evident. This study demonstrates that enamel thickness and EDJ shape vary among molars, between sexes, and among populations; these factors must be considered in the categorization and comparison of ape and human molars, particularly when isolated teeth or fossil taxa are included. Human relative enamel thickness encompasses most values reported for fossil apes and humans, suggesting limited taxonomic value when considered alone.
本研究对多样化的现代人类样本中的磨牙冠部横截面进行了检查,以量化牙釉质厚度和牙釉质 - 牙本质交界处(EDJ)形状的变异。组织学切片是从沿近中尖颊舌向切开的磨牙中获取的。使用数字化绘图板在显微照片上测量牙釉质帽面积、牙本质面积、EDJ长度和双颈直径。沿着EDJ定义了9个标志点,并对X和Y坐标进行数字化处理,以量化EDJ形状。上颌磨牙的牙釉质厚度各组成部分的值更大,导致其平均牙釉质厚度明显大于下颌磨牙。在两排磨牙中,从M1到M3平均牙釉质厚度均显著增加,这是由于上颌磨牙的牙釉质帽面积显著增加,而下颌磨牙的牙本质面积减小。在合并人群和个体人群的上颌磨牙中发现了EDJ形状的差异。还发现了性别差异;在某些牙齿类型中,男性的牙本质面积、EDJ长度和双颈直径显著更大,这导致女性的平均牙釉质明显更厚。在不同人群中,磨牙内部的牙釉质厚度和EDJ形状也存在差异,尽管几乎没有明显一致的趋势。本研究表明,牙釉质厚度和EDJ形状在磨牙之间、性别之间以及人群之间存在差异;在对猿类和人类磨牙进行分类和比较时,必须考虑这些因素,特别是当包括孤立牙齿或化石分类单元时。人类相对牙釉质厚度涵盖了大多数已报道的化石猿类和人类的值,单独考虑时表明其分类学价值有限。