Carpentier Melissa Y, Silovsky Jane F, Chaffin Mark
Department of Psychology, Oklahoma State University, Stillwater, OK, USA.
J Consult Clin Psychol. 2006 Jun;74(3):482-8. doi: 10.1037/0022-006X.74.3.482.
This study prospectively follows 135 children 5-12 years of age with sexual behavior problems from a randomized trial comparing a 12-session group cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT) with group play therapy and follows 156 general clinic children with nonsexual behavior problems. Ten-year follow-up data on future juvenile and adult arrests and child welfare perpetration reports were collected. The CBT group had significantly fewer future sex offenses than the play therapy group (2% vs. 10%) and did not differ from the general clinic comparison (3%), supporting the use of short-term CBT. There were no group differences in nonsexual offenses (21%). The findings do not support assumptions about persistent or difficult to modify risk and raise questions about policies and practices founded on this assumption.
本研究前瞻性地追踪了135名5至12岁有性行为问题的儿童,这些儿童来自一项随机试验,该试验比较了为期12节的团体认知行为疗法(CBT)与团体游戏疗法,并追踪了156名有非性行为问题的普通门诊儿童。收集了关于未来青少年和成人被捕以及儿童福利犯罪报告的十年随访数据。CBT组未来性犯罪的发生率显著低于游戏治疗组(2%对10%),与普通门诊对照组无差异(3%),这支持了短期CBT的应用。非性犯罪方面没有组间差异(21%)。这些发现不支持关于持续存在或难以改变的风险的假设,并对基于这一假设的政策和做法提出了质疑。