Selden Nathan R
Division of Pediatric Neurosurgery, Oregon Health & Science University, Portland, Oregon 97239, USA.
J Neurosurg. 2006 May;104(5 Suppl):302-4. doi: 10.3171/ped.2006.104.5.302.
Controversy exists regarding proper indications for surgical lysis of the terminal filum in children with voiding dysfunction and tethered spinal cord. Recently, surgery has been offered to children who have a normally positioned conus medullaris and no terminal filum abnormality visible on 1.5-tesla magnetic resonance images (referred to as minimal or occult tethered cord syndrome [TCS]). The author evaluates existing clinical and scientific evidence relevant to this controversy.
Five retrospective, observational, noncontrolled studies of surgical terminal filum lysis for occult TCS in children were identified. Two further studies in which the authors reported surgical results in children with a normal-level conus medullaris were also identified.
These studies document encouraging clinical outcomes following surgery. Clinicopathological evidence suggests that occult TCS may result from radiographically occult structural abnormalities of the terminal filum. Although a preponderance of Class III clinical evidence supports the use of surgical filum lysis to treat occult TCS, no Class I or II evidence exists. Clinical practice varies; therefore, performance of a prospective randomized clinical trial of surgical terminal filum lysis for the treatment of occult TCS is advocated.
对于存在排尿功能障碍和脊髓拴系的儿童,终丝手术松解的恰当指征存在争议。近来,手术已应用于圆锥位置正常且在1.5特斯拉磁共振成像上未见终丝异常的儿童(称为轻微或隐匿性脊髓拴系综合征 [TCS])。作者评估了与这一争议相关的现有临床和科学证据。
确定了五项关于儿童隐匿性TCS终丝手术松解的回顾性、观察性、非对照研究。还确定了另外两项研究,作者在其中报告了圆锥位置正常的儿童的手术结果。
这些研究记录了手术后令人鼓舞的临床结果。临床病理证据表明,隐匿性TCS可能源于终丝影像学上隐匿的结构异常。虽然大量III级临床证据支持使用手术终丝松解治疗隐匿性TCS,但不存在I级或II级证据。临床实践各不相同;因此,提倡对手术终丝松解治疗隐匿性TCS进行前瞻性随机临床试验。