Boldt J, Kling D, Zickmann B, Mühlhause M, Dapper F, Hempelmann G
Abteilung Anaesthesiologie und Operative Intensivmedizin, Justus-Liebig-Universität Giessen.
Anaesthesist. 1990 Jan;39(1):6-12.
Blood conservation is gaining more and more interest because of the increasing risks involved in homologous blood transfusions. Acute normovolemic hemodilution (ANH) is becoming an established technique even in cardiac surgery patients. The "optimal" kind of volume replacement, however, is still controversial. Thus, this study was carried out to investigate the hemodynamic response of 6 different hydroxyethyl starch (HES) solutions as volume replacement. METHODS. In 60 patients undergoing elective aortocoronary bypass surgery, acute, preoperative hemodilution was performed (10 ml/kg) and HES with different concentrations, molecular weight, and substitution was infused according to a randomized sequence: 1. 6% HES 450,000/0.7; 2. 10% HES 200,000/0.5; 3. 3% HES 200,000/0.5%; 4. 6% HES 40,000/0.5; 5. 6% HES 200,000/0.5; 6. 6% HES 200,000/0.62. All patients were monitored using a new pulmonary artery catheter that allows measurement of the right ventricular ejection fraction (RVEF), right ventricular enddiastolic volume (RVEDV), and right ventricular end systolic volume (RVESV) in addition to standard hemodynamic parameters. RESULTS. Immediately after finishing ANH the typical hemodynamic changes of hemodilution (HD) were apparent (decrease in peripheral resistance and increase in cardiac index (CI]. All 6 solutions investigated were effective in hemodynamic stabilization (no changes in mean arterial pressure (MAP), filling pressures (PCP, RAP), or heart rate (HR]. Forty min after ANH, however (before beginning extracorporeal circulation (ECC], there were significant differences between the groups: in groups 3 and 4 the increase in CI had already disappeared, and SVI in group 3 was even lower than the baseline values (-8%). In the other groups, a higher CI level remained even 40 min after ANH, which was most pronounced in groups 2 (+40%) and 5 (+43%). Right ventricular performance was not changed by ANH (RVEF unchanged in all groups). Forty min after hemodilution RVEDVI (-8%) and RVESVI (-16%) decreased significantly only in group 4, whereas in the other groups these parameters were still elevated. The most pronounced positive fluid balance after the end of ECC was found in group 4 (+850 ml); in these patients paO2 decreased significantly (-150 mmHg). CONCLUSIONS. The guarantee of stable hemodynamic conditions is a prerequisite when performing ANH in coronary surgery patients. The different physiochemical attributes of various HES solutions seem to be important, thus influencing their hemodynamic response. In this study, low-concentration (3% HES 200/0.5) and low-molecular (6% HES 40/0.5) HES solutions were less effective in stabilizing hemodynamics until the beginning of ECC. Additionally, their negative influence on fluid balance during ECC, followed by a deterioration in pulmonary function led to the conclusion that other solutions are preferable; in particular, 10% HES seems to be of advantage in these situations.
由于同种异体输血所涉及的风险不断增加,血液保护越来越受到关注。急性等容性血液稀释(ANH)甚至在心脏手术患者中已成为一种成熟的技术。然而,“最佳”的容量替代类型仍存在争议。因此,本研究旨在调查6种不同羟乙基淀粉(HES)溶液作为容量替代时的血流动力学反应。方法:在60例行择期主动脉冠状动脉搭桥手术的患者中,进行急性术前血液稀释(10 ml/kg),并根据随机顺序输注不同浓度、分子量和取代度的HES:1. 6% HES 450,000/0.7;2. 10% HES 200,000/0.5;3. 3% HES 200,000/0.5%;4. 6% HES 40,000/0.5;5. 6% HES 200,000/0.5;6. 6% HES 200,000/0.62。所有患者均使用一种新型肺动脉导管进行监测,该导管除了能测量标准血流动力学参数外,还能测量右心室射血分数(RVEF)、右心室舒张末期容积(RVEDV)和右心室收缩末期容积(RVESV)。结果:ANH结束后立即出现血液稀释(HD)典型的血流动力学变化(外周阻力降低,心脏指数(CI)增加)。所研究的6种溶液在血流动力学稳定方面均有效(平均动脉压(MAP)、充盈压(PCP、RAP)或心率(HR)无变化)。然而,ANH后40分钟(在开始体外循环(ECC)之前),各组之间存在显著差异:第3组和第4组CI的增加已经消失,第3组的每搏量指数(SVI)甚至低于基线值(-8%)。在其他组中,即使在ANH后40分钟,CI水平仍较高,在第2组(+40%)和第5组(+43%)中最为明显。ANH未改变右心室功能(所有组RVEF均未改变)。血液稀释后40分钟,仅第4组右心室舒张末期容积指数(RVEDVI)(-8%)和右心室收缩末期容积指数(RVESVI)(-16%)显著降低,而其他组这些参数仍升高。ECC结束后,第4组的液体正平衡最为明显(+850 ml);这些患者的动脉血氧分压(PaO2)显著降低(-150 mmHg)。结论:在冠状动脉手术患者中进行ANH时,保证血流动力学稳定是前提条件。各种HES溶液不同的理化特性似乎很重要,从而影响其血流动力学反应。在本研究中,低浓度(3% HES 200/0.5)和低分子(6% HES 40/0.5)HES溶液在ECC开始前稳定血流动力学方面效果较差。此外,它们对ECC期间液体平衡的负面影响,随后导致肺功能恶化,得出结论认为其他溶液更可取;特别是,10% HES在这些情况下似乎具有优势。