Rabinerson David, Horowitz Eran, Peled Yoav
Helen Schneider Hospital for Women, Rabin Medical Center, Petah Tikva.
Harefuah. 2006 Aug;145(8):587-91, 630.
Peer review is a process designed to ensure quality, integrity and novelty of scientific or medical studies, published in scientific journals. This process accompanies scientific publication since it began and is the cornerstone of scientific appreciation and acceptance. Since peer review is a non-transparent process and lacks standardized criteria for evaluation, it thereby attracts extensive criticism, as discussed in this article. Editors and reviewers of this journal have a special responsibility when discussing a submitted article, since this journal is the only scientific-medical platform in the Hebrew language.
同行评审是一个旨在确保发表在科学期刊上的科学或医学研究的质量、完整性和新颖性的过程。自科学出版开始以来,这个过程就一直伴随着它,并且是科学评价和接受的基石。如本文所讨论的,由于同行评审是一个不透明的过程且缺乏标准化的评估标准,因此它受到了广泛的批评。当讨论一篇提交的文章时,本期刊的编辑和审稿人负有特殊责任,因为本期刊是希伯来语唯一的科学医学平台。