Jaiprakash M, Gupta P K, Kumar Harsh
Department of Transfusion Medicine, Armed Forces Medical College, Pune.
Indian J Pathol Microbiol. 2006 Jul;49(3):370-2.
The direct (DAT) and indirect antiglobulin tests (IAT) are one of the most important diagnostic tools used in the investigation of immune mediated disorders. Recently, transfusion laboratories have seen the introduction of column technology in the form of the gel technology (GT). Aim of this study is to compare the conventional tube tests (CTT) and the GT for Coomb's test and to evaluate their sensitivity and specificity. 1656 samples were included in this study, in which 1054 samples were subjected to IAT and 602 samples were subjected to DAT Of the 602 samples tested for DAT, 587 (97.5%) showed concordant DAT results. DAT by the GT could detect 8.6% positivity as compared to 6.1% by CTT. The sensitivity and specificity of the GT was 100% and 97.3% respectively and its negative predictive value was 100%. Among the 1054 samples for IAT, 1041 (98. 8%) showed concordant results. The IAT by the GT showed 6.6% positivity as compared to 5.4% positivity by CTT The sensitivity, specificity and the positive and negative predictive value were 100%, 97.7%, 81.4% and 100% respectively. In conclusion, the GT is a better alternative to the CTT for both DAT and IAT. The GT is highly recommended to be implemented as a routine method of testing in all zonal / regional blood transfusion centers.
直接抗球蛋白试验(DAT)和间接抗球蛋白试验(IAT)是用于免疫介导疾病调查的最重要诊断工具之一。最近,输血实验室引入了凝胶技术(GT)形式的柱技术。本研究的目的是比较传统试管试验(CTT)和GT用于库姆斯试验的情况,并评估它们的敏感性和特异性。本研究纳入了1656份样本,其中1054份样本进行了IAT,602份样本进行了DAT。在602份进行DAT检测的样本中,587份(97.5%)显示DAT结果一致。与CTT的6.1%相比,GT检测DAT的阳性率为8.6%。GT的敏感性和特异性分别为100%和97.3%,其阴性预测值为100%。在1054份进行IAT的样本中,1041份(98.8%)显示结果一致。与CTT的5.4%阳性率相比,GT检测IAT的阳性率为6.6%。其敏感性、特异性、阳性预测值和阴性预测值分别为100%、97.7%、81.4%和100%。总之,对于DAT和IAT,GT是比CTT更好的选择。强烈建议在所有地区/区域输血中心将GT作为常规检测方法实施。