The reliability of relative anion-cation permeabilities deduced from reversal (dilution) potential measurements in ion channel studies.

Measurements of anion-cation permeability ratios (e.g., PCl/PNa) are most readily made by measuring changes in zero-current reversal potential when the salt concentration on one side of the membrane (e.g., external NaCl) is decreased. This is particularly useful for measuring changes in ion selectivity in wild-type and mutant channels, such as those of the ligand-gated ion channel superfamily, and has shown that many of these channels have a significant permeability to counter-ions. One Brownian dynamics study of ion permeation through such narrow ion channels failed to observe such counter-ion movement, although later, another Brownian dynamics study did observe counter-ion movement through simulations of the same channels. The question has been raised as to the reliability of such reversal potential measurements for determining permeability ratios, particularly given the use of an equation such as the Goldman-Hodgkin-Katz (GHK) equation, which is often used to calculate such ratios. A new derivation of the GHK equation in terms of activity coefficients is also included. The application of irreversible thermodynamics will be shown to qualitatively support the reliability of such experimental anion-cation permeability values derived from reversal potential measurements. It will then be shown that for such zero-current situations, different electrodiffusion models, with very different underlying assumptions, produce almost identical relative permeabilities (and reversal potentials). Finally, the results of the two Brownian dynamics simulation studies and the relationship between reversal potentials and relative permeability will be discussed.