Lewis Catherine F, Fields Cynthia, Rainey Elizabeth
University of Connecticut Health Center, Farmington, CT, USA.
J Am Acad Psychiatry Law. 2006;34(3):324-32.
The objective of this study was to examine a sample (n = 99) of elderly forensic evaluees to describe the psychiatric, medical, legal, and demographic characteristics of the sample and to examine which of these factors is associated with violent charges. Clinical data were gathered through retrospective chart review of patients aged 60 and over who were referred for criminal responsibility/competency-to-stand-trial evaluations from 1991 to 1998 at William S. Hall Psychiatric Institute in Columbia, South Carolina. Most (67.7%) of the sample was alcohol dependent, nearly one half (44.4%) had dementia, and close to one third (32.3%) had antisocial personality disorder. The majority of patients (60.6%) were facing violent charges and most (80.8%) were recidivists. In multivariate analysis, race, outpatient treatment status, crime location, and paranoia were all associated with violent charges. The implications and limitations of these data as applied to forensic treatment settings are discussed.
本研究的目的是对一组老年法医评估对象(n = 99)进行调查,以描述该样本的精神、医学、法律和人口统计学特征,并探究这些因素中哪些与暴力指控相关。临床数据通过对1991年至1998年间在南卡罗来纳州哥伦比亚市威廉·S·霍尔精神病学研究所被转介进行刑事责任/受审能力评估的60岁及以上患者的病历进行回顾性审查收集。样本中大多数(67.7%)有酒精依赖,近一半(44.4%)患有痴呆症,近三分之一(32.3%)有反社会人格障碍。大多数患者(60.6%)面临暴力指控,且大多数(80.8%)是惯犯。在多变量分析中,种族、门诊治疗状况、犯罪地点和偏执狂均与暴力指控相关。本文讨论了这些数据应用于法医治疗环境的意义和局限性。