Argstatter H, Plinkert P, Bolay H V
Deutsches Zentrum für Musiktherapieforschung (Viktor Dulger Institut) DZM e. V., Heidelberg.
HNO. 2007 May;55(5):375-83. doi: 10.1007/s00106-006-1478-4.
Chronic tinnitus, one of the most common disorders in ENT medicine, requires comprehensive and interdisciplinary treatment.
An innovative music therapy approach, developed at the German Center for Music Therapy Research in cooperation with the ENT clinic of the University of Heidelberg ("Heidelberg Model"), strives to integrate the tinnitus sound into a musically controllable acoustic process. The aim of the present study is to evaluate the effectiveness of this current treatment.
We carried out a prospective, two-armed (music therapy group vs control group) study with 20 patients (10 males, 10 females; mean age 51+/-7 years), suffering from decompensated chronic tinnitus (mean score in the Tinnitus Questionnaire TQ=46.8+/-9.6). The target variables involved TQ values, pre- and post-measurements, and follow-up after 3 and 6 months.
Group comparison yields a highly statistically and clinically significant decrease in mean TQ-scores pre- and post in the music therapy group by 25 points or 52% on average as compared to 2 points (4%) in the control group [univariate ANOVA: (F(1,31)=14.19, P=0.001), effect size d=1.73]. Logarithmic regression analysis reveals a fast onset and long lasting effect of music therapy (B=-8.9; F(1,125)=32.11, P=0.000).
The effectiveness of this highly economic approach was proven as the innovative music therapy concept yields statistically and clinically significant results which remain stable throughout follow-up. Further investigations with larger sample sizes and using brain imaging should strengthen these findings.
慢性耳鸣是耳鼻喉科最常见的疾病之一,需要综合和跨学科治疗。
德国音乐治疗研究中心与海德堡大学耳鼻喉科诊所合作开发的一种创新音乐治疗方法(“海德堡模式”),致力于将耳鸣声融入到一个音乐可控的声学过程中。本研究的目的是评估这种当前治疗方法的有效性。
我们对20例患者(10例男性,10例女性;平均年龄51±7岁)进行了一项前瞻性双臂研究(音乐治疗组与对照组),这些患者患有失代偿性慢性耳鸣(耳鸣问卷TQ的平均得分=46.8±9.6)。目标变量包括TQ值、治疗前后测量值以及3个月和6个月后的随访。
组间比较显示,音乐治疗组治疗前后的平均TQ得分在统计学和临床意义上均有显著下降,平均下降25分或52%,而对照组下降2分(4%)[单因素方差分析:(F(1,31)=14.19,P=0.001),效应大小d=1.73]。对数回归分析显示音乐治疗起效快且效果持久(B=-8.9;F(1,125)=32.11,P=0.000)。
这种高度经济的方法的有效性得到了证实,因为创新的音乐治疗概念在统计学和临床意义上均产生了显著结果,并且在整个随访过程中保持稳定。进一步采用更大样本量并使用脑成像的研究应强化这些发现。