Zhou Muchu, Smith G Troy
Department of Biology, Indiana University, Bloomington, IN 47405, USA.
J Exp Biol. 2006 Dec;209(Pt 23):4809-18. doi: 10.1242/jeb.02579.
Electrocommunication signals of electric fish vary across species, sexes and individuals. The diversity of these signals and the relative simplicity of the neural circuits controlling them make them a model well-suited for studying the mechanisms, evolution and sexual differentiation of behavior. In most wave-type gymnotiform knifefishes, electric organ discharge (EOD) frequency and EOD modulations known as chirps are sexually dimorphic. In the most speciose gymnotiform family, the Apteronotidae, EOD frequency is higher in males than females in some species, but lower in males than females in others. Sex differences in EOD frequency and chirping, however, have been examined in only three apteronotid species in a single genus, Apteronotus. To understand the diversity of electrocommunication signals, we characterized these behaviors in another genus, Adontosternarchus. Electrocommunication signals of Adontosternarchus devenanzii differed from those of Apteronotus in several ways. Unlike in Apteronotus, EOD frequency was not sexually dimorphic in A. devenanzii. Furthermore, although A. devenanzii chirped in response to playbacks simulating conspecific EODs, the number of chirps did not vary with different stimulus frequencies. A. devenanzii chirps also differed in structure from Apteronotus chirps. Whereas Apteronotus species produce functionally distinct chirp types differing in frequency modulation (FM), A. devenanzii produced only high-frequency chirps that had either single or multiple frequency peaks. Males produced more multi-peaked chirps than females. Thus, the temporal structure of chirps, rather than the amount of FM, delineated chirp types in A. devenanzii. Our results demonstrate that the structure, function and sexual dimorphism of electrocommunication signals are evolutionary labile in apteronotids and may be useful for understanding the diversity of sexually dimorphic behavior.
电鱼的电通信信号因物种、性别和个体而异。这些信号的多样性以及控制它们的神经回路相对简单,使其成为一个非常适合研究行为机制、进化和性别分化的模型。在大多数波形裸背电鳗科刀鱼中,电器官放电(EOD)频率和被称为啁啾声的EOD调制在性别上存在差异。在种类最多的裸背电鳗科中,在某些物种中,雄性的EOD频率高于雌性,但在其他物种中,雄性的EOD频率低于雌性。然而,仅在裸背电鳗属的三个物种中研究了EOD频率和啁啾声的性别差异。为了了解电通信信号的多样性,我们对另一个属——无胸电鳗属的这些行为进行了特征描述。德氏无胸电鳗的电通信信号在几个方面与裸背电鳗属的不同。与裸背电鳗属不同,德氏无胸电鳗的EOD频率在性别上没有差异。此外,尽管德氏无胸电鳗会对模拟同种EOD的回放做出啁啾声反应,但啁啾声的数量不会随不同的刺激频率而变化。德氏无胸电鳗的啁啾声在结构上也与裸背电鳗属的啁啾声不同。裸背电鳗属的物种会产生功能上不同的啁啾声类型,其调频(FM)不同,而德氏无胸电鳗只产生具有单个或多个频率峰值的高频啁啾声。雄性产生的多峰啁啾声比雌性多。因此,在德氏无胸电鳗中,啁啾声的时间结构而非调频量划分了啁啾声类型。我们的结果表明,电通信信号的结构、功能和性别二态性在裸背电鳗科中在进化上是不稳定的,可能有助于理解性别二态性行为的多样性。