Khan Ashraful I, Huq Sayeeda, Malek Mohammed A, Hossain Md lqbal, Talukder Kaisar A, Faruque Abu S G, Salam Mohammed A
ICDDR,B: Center for Health and Population Research, Dhaka, Bangladesh.
Southeast Asian J Trop Med Public Health. 2006 Jul;37(4):747-54.
We evaluated the usefulness of enumeration of fecal leukocytes and erythrocytes in making an early diagnosis of Shigella infection, where Shigella is a leading cause of invasive diarrhea. Stool specimens from 561 invasive diarrhea patients were submitted for microscopic examination. A presumptive diagnosis of shigellosis based on microscopic examination was made in 389 of them; 227 had stool cultures positive for Shigella spp (Shigella patients). One hundred sixty-two patients with no detectable Shigella infection (non-Shigella invasive diarrhea cases) served as a comparison group. Two hundred twenty-seven randomly selected Shigella patients and 227 non-Shigella infectious diarrhea cases from the surveillance system database of the hospital constituted another group for comparative evaluation. The stool specimens of the patients were examined under the microscope, and isolation, biochemical characterization and serotyping of Shigella were performed. In comparison with non-Shigella invasive diarrhea cases, the presence of >50 WBC/hpf in association with any number of RBC in the fecal sample had a modest sensitivity of 67%, specificity of 59%, positive predictive value of 70%, negative predictive value of 56%, accuracy of 64%, and positive likelihood ratio of 1.6 in predicting shigellosis. Comparison between Shigella and non-Shigella infectious diarrhea patients revealed the presence of >20 WBC/hpf was a less accurate predictor of shigellosis (sensitivity 51%, specificity 88%, positive predictive value 81%, negative predictive value 64%, accuracy 69%, and positive likelihood ratio 4.1). Direct microscopical examination of stool specimens for the presence of WBC and RBC may facilitate the early diagnosis of shigellosis, and may be a cheap alternative to stool culture in this setting.
志贺氏菌是侵袭性腹泻的主要病因,我们评估了粪便白细胞和红细胞计数在志贺氏菌感染早期诊断中的作用。对561例侵袭性腹泻患者的粪便标本进行显微镜检查。其中389例根据显微镜检查初步诊断为志贺氏菌病;227例粪便培养志贺氏菌属阳性(志贺氏菌患者)。162例未检测到志贺氏菌感染的患者(非志贺氏菌侵袭性腹泻病例)作为对照组。从医院监测系统数据库中随机选取227例志贺氏菌患者和227例非志贺氏菌感染性腹泻病例组成另一组进行比较评估。对患者的粪便标本进行显微镜检查,并进行志贺氏菌的分离、生化鉴定和血清分型。与非志贺氏菌侵袭性腹泻病例相比,粪便样本中白细胞>50个/高倍视野且伴有任意数量红细胞时,预测志贺氏菌病的敏感性为67%,特异性为59%,阳性预测值为70%,阴性预测值为56%,准确性为64%,阳性似然比为1.6。志贺氏菌患者与非志贺氏菌感染性腹泻患者的比较显示,白细胞>20个/高倍视野对志贺氏菌病的预测准确性较低(敏感性51%,特异性88%,阳性预测值81%,阴性预测值64%,准确性69%,阳性似然比4.1)。对粪便标本进行白细胞和红细胞的直接显微镜检查可能有助于志贺氏菌病的早期诊断,在这种情况下可能是一种比粪便培养便宜的替代方法。