Fang Yue, Fu Xiuxin, Chi Leiting, Wang Guanglin, Yang Tianfu
Department of Orthopedic Surgery, West China Hospital, Sichuan University, Chengdu 610041, China.
Sheng Wu Yi Xue Gong Cheng Xue Za Zhi. 2006 Oct;23(5):1041-4.
This study was sought to compare and evaluate the biomechanical properities of rotating-arm self-locking intramedullary nails (RSIN) with domestic femoral intramedullary nail (DFIN) in communited femoral shaft fractures. A 2 cm midshaft defect was created on seven pairs of cadaver femur, and fixed with two kinds of intramedullary nails. Then the torsion, four-point bending and axial loading to failure were tested on these models. The load versus deformation curve was generated from the load recorded by the load cell and the deformation simultaneously recorded by the linear variable displacement transducer. The mean torsional stiffness of the femora fixed with RSIN was 0.98 Nm/degree, which was significantly less than that fixed with the similar nails reported in documents, and the mean value of bending stiffness of the femur fixed with DFIN was larger than that of the femur fixed with RBIN, but there was no significant statistic difference. For use in fracture models under compression load beyond 1200 N, the RBIN was more rigid than DFIN, which provided the biggest load. All the parameters of the test with nails were greater than that for femur fixed with nails. In conclusion, FBIN probably provides enough strength and rigidity for use in communited femoral shaft fractures.
本研究旨在比较和评估旋转臂自锁髓内钉(RSIN)与国产股骨髓内钉(DFIN)在股骨干粉碎性骨折中的生物力学性能。在七对尸体股骨上制造2cm的骨干中段缺损,并用两种髓内钉进行固定。然后对这些模型进行扭转、四点弯曲和轴向加载至破坏测试。根据称重传感器记录的载荷和线性可变位移传感器同时记录的变形生成载荷-变形曲线。用RSIN固定的股骨平均扭转刚度为0.98 Nm/度,明显低于文献报道的类似髓内钉固定的股骨,用DFIN固定的股骨弯曲刚度平均值大于用RBIN固定的股骨,但无显著统计学差异。对于压缩载荷超过1200N的骨折模型,RBIN比DFIN更具刚性,提供的载荷最大。所有带钉测试参数均大于带钉固定股骨的参数。总之,FBIN可能为股骨干粉碎性骨折提供足够的强度和刚度。