Ravindran Vinod, Sennik Devesh, Hughes Rod A
Department of Medicine, St Peter's Hospital, Guildford Road, Chertsey, KT 16 0PZ, UK.
Emerg Radiol. 2007 Jan;13(4):181-5; discussion 187,189. doi: 10.1007/s10140-006-0531-7. Epub 2006 Nov 23.
This study was conducted to evaluate the appropriateness of the out-of-hours computed tomography (CT) head scans (scans performed outside normal working hours) in a large district general hospital in the United Kingdom. CT scan request forms and CT reports of adult patients were reviewed who had their CT head scans done between 1700 and 0900 h the next day and all weekend and national holidays in the study period of 4 months. Information regarding change in the patient management resulting from CT scan was extracted from review of patients' case notes. An urgent CT head scan request was deemed appropriate if it led to an immediate change in a patient's management. Appropriateness of the requests according to the various guidelines was also evaluated. One hundred and twenty-one patients were included in the study. Majority (70%) of the scans were requested by the emergency department. Eighty-one (66%) scans were both requested and performed between 1700 and 2200 h. Immediate change in management of 80% patients occurred. In 20 (17%), the change in management occurred only after 0900 h the next day and in 4 (3%), management did not change at all. Common scenarios involving change in patient's management included intracranial bleed requiring urgent neurosurgical intervention and hemorrhagic stroke being ruled out. Out-of-hours CT head scans also facilitated early discharge of the patients with head injuries and headache from the hospital. This retrospective study has found that a high proportion of out-of-hours CT head scans were appropriate and led to change in the patient's immediate medical care.
本研究旨在评估英国一家大型地区综合医院非工作时间头部计算机断层扫描(CT)(在正常工作时间以外进行的扫描)的合理性。回顾了成年患者的CT扫描申请表和CT报告,这些患者在研究期间的4个月内,于17:00至次日09:00以及整个周末和国家法定节假日进行了头部CT扫描。从患者病历回顾中提取了因CT扫描导致患者管理发生变化的信息。如果紧急头部CT扫描请求导致患者管理立即改变,则认为该请求是合理的。还根据各种指南评估了请求的合理性。121名患者纳入研究。大多数(70%)扫描由急诊科请求。81次(66%)扫描在17:00至22:00之间被请求并进行。80%的患者管理立即发生改变。20名患者(17%)的管理改变仅在次日09:00之后发生,4名患者(3%)的管理根本没有改变。涉及患者管理改变的常见情况包括需要紧急神经外科干预的颅内出血和排除出血性中风。非工作时间头部CT扫描也有助于头部受伤和头痛患者早日出院。这项回顾性研究发现,很大一部分非工作时间头部CT扫描是合理的,并导致了患者即时医疗护理的改变。