Couloigner V, Sterkers O, Redondo A, Rey A
Skull Base Surg. 1998;8(4):163-8. doi: 10.1055/s-2008-1058177.
This retrospective study analyzed 29 cerebral abscesses of ear, nose, and throat (ENT) origin. The mean follow-up of patients was 37 months. ENT etiologies included 45% otitis media (n = 13), 48% sinusitis (n = 14), and 7% ethmoidal sinus tumors (n = 2). Thirty-eight percent (n = 5) of otogenic abscesses occurred within 15 days after a mastoidectomy. Sinogenic abscesses were never due to surgery but were associated in 31% of cases (n = 5) with anterior skull base defects. The main locations of otogenic abscesses were the temporal lobe (54%; n = 7) and the cerebellum (23%; n = 3), whereas sinogenic abscesses were located in the frontal lobe in 75% of cases (n = 12). Because of this location, sinogenic abscesses were less symptomatic than otogenic ones and had greater size and encapsulation at the time of diagnosis. Thus, they required longer antibiotic treatment (p = 0.05) and more numerous surgical drainages (p = 0.02). Bacteriologic abscesses samples were positive in 90% of cases. Bacteria found in brain abscesses were different from the ones found in ENT samples in 62% of cases. Thus, the results of ENT bacteriologic samples were not helpful for choosing adequate antibiotic agents in case of negative brain abscess samples. Although mortality was not significantly higher in otogenic abscesses (31%; n = 4) than in sinogenic ones (6%; n = 1, p = 0.08), otogenic abscesses appeared more threatening. Indeed, they represented 80% (n = 4) of lethal cases and encompassed more clinical or radiological prognosis pejorative factors than sinogenic ones (p = 0.006). In conclusion, higher danger of otogenic abscesses mainly resulted both from their temporal or cerebellous locations and from the bacteria that were more frequently resistant to antibiotics.
这项回顾性研究分析了29例源于耳鼻喉科(ENT)的脑脓肿。患者的平均随访时间为37个月。耳鼻喉科病因包括45%的中耳炎(n = 13)、48%的鼻窦炎(n = 14)和7%的筛窦肿瘤(n = 2)。38%(n = 5)的耳源性脓肿发生在乳突切除术后15天内。鼻源性脓肿从未因手术引起,但在31%的病例(n = 5)中与前颅底缺损有关。耳源性脓肿的主要部位是颞叶(54%;n = 7)和小脑(23%;n = 3),而鼻源性脓肿在75%的病例(n = 12)中位于额叶。由于这个位置,鼻源性脓肿的症状比耳源性脓肿轻,在诊断时体积更大且有包膜。因此,它们需要更长时间的抗生素治疗(p = 0.05)和更多次的手术引流(p = 0.02)。90%的病例中细菌学脓肿样本呈阳性。62%的病例中,脑脓肿中发现的细菌与耳鼻喉科样本中发现的细菌不同。因此,在脑脓肿样本为阴性的情况下,耳鼻喉科细菌学样本的结果无助于选择合适的抗生素。虽然耳源性脓肿的死亡率(31%;n = 4)并不显著高于鼻源性脓肿(6%;n = 1,p = 0.08),但耳源性脓肿似乎更具威胁性。事实上,它们占致命病例的80%(n = 4),并且比鼻源性脓肿包含更多的临床或放射学预后不良因素(p = 0.006)。总之,耳源性脓肿的更高危险性主要源于其颞叶或小脑的位置以及更频繁地对抗生素耐药的细菌。