Khan Nasrin K, Goode Kevin M, Cleland John G F, Rigby Alan S, Freemantle Nick, Eastaugh Joanne, Clark Andrew L, de Silva Ramesh, Calvert Melanie J, Swedberg Karl, Komajda Michael, Mareev Viu, Follath Ferenc
University of Hull, Kingston upon Hull, United Kingdom.
Eur J Heart Fail. 2007 May;9(5):491-501. doi: 10.1016/j.ejheart.2006.11.003. Epub 2007 Jan 9.
Most patients suspected of having heart failure (HF) will get a 12-lead electrocardiogram (ECG) but its utility for excluding HF or assisting in its management has rarely been investigated.
The EuroHeart Failure survey identified 11,327 patients hospitalised with a suspected diagnosis of HF from 115 hospitals in 24 countries. ECGs were obtained from 9315 patients, of whom 5934 had cardiac imaging tests. The utility of the ECG was assessed for excluding or diagnosing major structural heart disease (MSHD) or major left ventricular systolic dysfunction (MLVSD) and for therapeutic decision making.
MSHD was present in 70% and MLVSD in 54% of patients overall but in only 21% and 5%, respectively, if the ECG was entirely normal. However, <2% of patients had a normal ECG. No single ECG characteristic identified a probability <25% of MSHD or <20% of MLVSD. Patients with QRS width >or=120 ms or anterior pathological Q-waves had a probability >80% of MSHD and >70% of MLVSD. Diagnostic models suggested that electrocardiographic criteria alone were not accurate for the diagnosis or exclusion of important heart disease in this population. However, 2468 patients (42%) had an electrocardiographic finding that should be used to guide the choice of therapy.
A normal ECG is rare in patients with suspected HF but has limited diagnostic value in this setting. The ECG has an important role in guiding therapy.
大多数疑似心力衰竭(HF)的患者会接受12导联心电图(ECG)检查,但其在排除HF或辅助HF治疗方面的作用很少被研究。
欧洲心力衰竭调查从24个国家的115家医院中识别出11327例因疑似HF诊断而住院的患者。从9315例患者中获取了ECG,其中5934例患者进行了心脏成像检查。评估ECG在排除或诊断主要结构性心脏病(MSHD)或主要左心室收缩功能障碍(MLVSD)以及治疗决策方面的作用。
总体上,70%的患者存在MSHD,54%的患者存在MLVSD,但如果ECG完全正常,这一比例分别仅为21%和5%。然而,<2%的患者ECG正常。没有单一的ECG特征能确定MSHD概率<25%或MLVSD概率<20%。QRS波宽度≥120毫秒或存在前壁病理性Q波的患者,MSHD概率>80%,MLVSD概率>70%。诊断模型表明,仅靠心电图标准在该人群中诊断或排除重要心脏病并不准确。然而,2468例患者(42%)有可用于指导治疗选择的心电图表现。
疑似HF患者中ECG正常的情况很少见,但在此情况下诊断价值有限。ECG在指导治疗方面具有重要作用。