Mahoney Kevin J, Fishman Nancy Wieler, Doty Pamela, Squillace Marie R
Boston College Graduate School of Social Work, 314 Hammond Street, Chestnut Hill, MA 02467, USA.
Health Serv Res. 2007 Feb;42(1 Pt 2):550-66. doi: 10.1111/j.1475-6773.2006.00676.x.
This paper reflects on the progress of the original Cash and Counseling states, and shows how this model has spread, how it has evolved over time, and what is left to improve. It then discusses the generalizability of the Cash and Counseling approach beyond long-term care and ventures some thoughts on what still needs to be learned. Finally, this paper suggests some of the contingencies that could affect the diffusion of this innovation.
DATA SOURCES/STUDY SETTING: Drawing from ten years of experiences with the fifteen Cash and Counseling states, plus their analyses of current trends and future opportunities and threats, the framers of the Cash and Counseling model reflect on future directions.
This paper is essentially a policy-driven analysis of how the Cash and Counseling model has been sustained and disseminated, how it is likely to develop, and what still needs to be learned.
The basic Cash and Counseling model appears adaptable to different state environments and populations, but that hypothesis will be severely tested as more and more states seek to replicate. As one step to promote flexibility while capturing and preserving the essence of the model that led to such promising research results, the Cash & Counseling National Program Office developed a "Vision Statement".
The Cash and Counseling approach is not for everyone, but it is clearly a choice many participants desire. Its development merits monitoring.
本文回顾了“现金与咨询”模式最初实施的各州所取得的进展,展示了该模式是如何传播的、随着时间推移是如何演变的以及仍有待改进之处。接着讨论了“现金与咨询”方法在长期护理领域之外的普遍适用性,并对仍需了解的内容提出了一些想法。最后,本文提出了一些可能影响这一创新传播的意外情况。
数据来源/研究背景:基于“现金与咨询”模式实施的15个州的十年经验,以及对当前趋势、未来机遇和威胁的分析,“现金与咨询”模式的制定者对未来方向进行了反思。
本文本质上是一项政策驱动的分析,探讨了“现金与咨询”模式是如何得以维持和传播的、可能如何发展以及仍需了解什么。
基本的“现金与咨询”模式似乎适用于不同的州环境和人群,但随着越来越多的州试图复制该模式,这一假设将受到严峻考验。作为在保持灵活性的同时抓住并保留该模式核心要点(正是这一核心要点带来了如此有前景的研究成果)的一步,“现金与咨询”国家项目办公室制定了一份“愿景声明”。
“现金与咨询”方法并非适用于所有人,但显然是许多参与者所期望的一种选择。其发展情况值得监测。