Maher Michael M, Hodnett Philip A, Kalra Mannudeep K
Department of Radiology, Cork University Hospital, Wilton, Cork, Ireland.
Radiology. 2007 Mar;242(3):658-70. doi: 10.1148/radiol.2423060008.
When introducing new interventional radiology techniques or devices, it is important to learn from previous experiences and to remember that there are numerous examples of new techniques that were initially enthusiastically promoted and then subsequently abandoned when early promise was not realized. Appropriateness of new or established interventional radiology techniques to specific clinical conditions must be determined from clinical experience, from communication with experts in the field and/or careful review of available medical literature, and on an individual patient basis by means of review of clinical notes and diagnostic imaging studies. Several paradigms for evidence-based practice (EBP) exist. One model proposes that a central specialized process involving academic centers should primarily construct valid guidelines to direct practice at all levels of medical practice ("top-down" model). An alternative model integrates "the best research evidence with clinical expertise and patient values" ("bottom-up" model). This article will focus on the bottom-up model and describe the use of EBP by individual practitioners or groups of practitioners in optimizing literature review and critical appraisal. EBP is applied to two scenarios as a means of deciding the appropriateness of introducing interventional radiology techniques in a community hospital setting. The authors will also briefly discuss other applications for EBP techniques in interventional radiology, including development of practice guidelines or policy to ensure appropriate and safe practices.
在引入新的介入放射学技术或设备时,借鉴以往经验很重要,要记住有许多新技术的例子,这些技术最初被热情推广,但由于早期的承诺未能实现,随后被放弃。新的或已有的介入放射学技术对特定临床情况的适用性,必须根据临床经验、与该领域专家的交流和/或对现有医学文献的仔细回顾来确定,并在个体患者层面通过查阅临床记录和诊断影像学研究来确定。循证医学实践(EBP)有几种模式。一种模式提出,一个涉及学术中心的核心专门流程应主要构建有效的指南,以指导各级医疗实践中的操作(“自上而下”模式)。另一种模式将“最佳研究证据与临床专业知识和患者价值观”整合在一起(“自下而上”模式)。本文将重点关注自下而上模式,并描述个体从业者或从业者群体如何利用循证医学实践来优化文献综述和批判性评价。循证医学实践被应用于两种情况,作为在社区医院环境中决定引入介入放射学技术是否合适的一种手段。作者还将简要讨论循证医学实践技术在介入放射学中的其他应用,包括制定实践指南或政策以确保操作的恰当性和安全性。