Fergusson David M, Boden Joseph M, Horwood L John
Christchurch Health and Development Study, Christchurch, New Zealand.
Perspect Sex Reprod Health. 2007 Mar;39(1):6-12. doi: 10.1363/3900607.
Young women frequently cite concerns about the effects of unplanned pregnancies on future life course outcomes, including education, employment and relationships, as reasons for seeking abortion. There is relatively little evidence as to whether abortion leads to improved life course outcomes for young women who choose this option.
Data from 492 women participating in a 25-year longitudinal study of a New Zealand birth cohort were used in regression models that examined the relationship between pregnancy and abortion history prior to age 21 and selected social and economic outcomes at ages 21-25.
Compared with young women who became pregnant before age 21 but did not seek an abortion, young women who had an abortion had significantly better outcomes on six out of 10 measures spanning education, income, welfare dependence and domestic violence. Adjustment for confounding factors indicated that most of these differences were explained by family, social and educational characteristics that were present prior to pregnancy. Nonetheless, even after adjustment for confounding factors, young women who had abortions had higher levels of subsequent educational achievement than those who became pregnant but did not have abortions.
Abortion may mitigate some effects of early unplanned pregnancy. However, further study of its potential risks and benefits is needed so that women can make fully informed decisions as to whether to terminate unintended pregnancies.
年轻女性经常将对意外怀孕对未来人生轨迹结果(包括教育、就业和人际关系)的影响的担忧,作为寻求堕胎的理由。关于堕胎是否会为选择这种方式的年轻女性带来更好的人生轨迹结果,相关证据相对较少。
对参与新西兰一个出生队列25年纵向研究的492名女性的数据进行回归模型分析,该模型考察了21岁之前的怀孕和堕胎史与21至25岁时选定的社会和经济结果之间的关系。
与21岁之前怀孕但未寻求堕胎的年轻女性相比,堕胎的年轻女性在涵盖教育、收入、福利依赖和家庭暴力的10项指标中的6项上有显著更好的结果。对混杂因素进行调整后表明,这些差异大多可由怀孕前就已存在的家庭、社会和教育特征来解释。尽管如此,即使在对混杂因素进行调整之后,堕胎的年轻女性随后的教育成就水平仍高于怀孕但未堕胎的女性。
堕胎可能会减轻早期意外怀孕的一些影响。然而,需要对其潜在风险和益处进行进一步研究,以便女性能够就是否终止意外怀孕做出充分知情的决定。