Hans Mark G, Teng Chi-Ming, Liao Ching-Cheng, Chen Yi-Horng, Yang Chin-Yuh
Department of Orthodontics, Case Western Reserve University, Cleveland, Ohio, USA.
World J Orthod. 2007 Spring;8(1):45-64.
Evidence-based decision making is gaining increased emphasis in medicine and dentistry. Since orthodontics is both an art and a science, not all decisions can be based solely on scientific findings. However, to the extent that orthodontics is a science and is based on the principles of scientific method, the clinician can practice evidence-based decision making. This article summarizes the results of 6 case-controlled studies on treatment changes in deep bite or open bite.
All studies used the Bolton Brush Growth Study as a source for untreated controls. Strategies for correction of deep bite included cervical pull headgear, bionator therapy, and Tweed edgewise mechanotherapy. Open-bite strategies included 4 premolar extraction, 4 first molar extraction, and active vertical corrector therapy. The changes in 6 variables involved in overlap of the incisor teeth (changes in the maxilla and mandible, as well as tipping and bodily movements of the maxillary and mandibular incisors) were summed at the occlusal plane.
Extraction of permanent teeth influences vertical facial growth, growth of the mandible is a major factor in the correction of deep bite, and tipping of the incisor teeth is an important contributor to open-bite correction. Two clinical cases that demonstrate the application of this analysis are presented. The first case involves an open bite treated with extraction of 4 premolars, and the second is a nonextraction deep-bite case treated with a Herbst appliance, followed by fixed appliances.
Case-controlled studies can help practitioners decide among various treatment strategies for vertical overbite problems.
循证决策在医学和牙科学领域正日益受到重视。由于正畸既是一门艺术也是一门科学,并非所有决策都能仅基于科学发现。然而,就正畸作为一门科学且基于科学方法的原则而言,临床医生可以践行循证决策。本文总结了6项关于深覆合或开颌治疗变化的病例对照研究结果。
所有研究均将博尔顿刷牙生长研究作为未治疗对照的来源。深覆合的矫治策略包括颈牵引头帽、生物调节器治疗和Tweed方丝弓矫治技术。开颌策略包括拔除4颗前磨牙、拔除4颗第一磨牙以及主动垂直矫治器治疗。在咬合平面汇总了涉及切牙覆合的6个变量的变化(上颌和下颌的变化,以及上颌和下颌切牙的倾斜和整体移动)。
恒牙拔除会影响垂直面部生长,下颌生长是深覆合矫治的主要因素,切牙倾斜是开颌矫治的重要因素。展示了两个应用该分析的临床病例。第一个病例是拔除4颗前磨牙治疗的开颌,第二个是使用Herbst矫治器治疗后再用固定矫治器治疗的不拔牙深覆合病例。
病例对照研究有助于从业者在针对垂直覆合问题的各种治疗策略中做出决策。