Mechanical behavior of intact and low-grade degenerated cartilage.

Young's modulus, elastic and plastic deformation, mechanical hardness and load at failure were determined for low-grade degenerated hyaline cartilage in a porcine model. Osteochondral plugs from the medial condyle of 30 female pigs were used. Cartilage defects were classified using the International Cartilage Repair Society (ICRS) protocol. Mechanical hardness was measured using a Shore A testing device. Total stiffness and plastic deformation was evaluated in the range 50-200 N using a 5-mm indenter. The load at failure was then determined. ICRS grade I specimens showed significantly lower stiffness than grade 0 specimens. ICRS grade 0 specimen showed no significant plastic deformation within the load range 25-100 N. In degenerated cartilage, plastic deformation started at a significantly lower load (50 N). The Young's modulus at 25 N in ICRS grade 0 specimens (18.8 MPa) was significantly higher than in grade I (11.1 MPa) or grade II (10.5 MPa) specimens. Intact cartilage showed significantly higher tension at failure and mechanical Shore A hardness. Young's modulus and tension at failure showed strong correlation. Cartilage degeneration is associated with a significant loss of elasticity and mechanical stress resistance. Shore hardness measurement is an adequate method for rapid biomechanical evaluation of cartilage specimens.