Mion G, Ricouard S
Département d'anesthésie-réanimation, hôpital d'instruction des armées du Val-de-Grâce, Paris cedex 05, France.
Ann Fr Anesth Reanim. 2007 Jul-Aug;26(7-8):638-48. doi: 10.1016/j.annfar.2007.03.007. Epub 2007 May 3.
In 2003 were promulgated the texts regulating rest and safety, in the USA (approved by the ACGME) and in France (January 9th, 2001 and September 14th, 2001). The institution of the "rest for safety", an eleven hours duration interruption of activity, immediately after a night-call, can be viewed as a progress in the search for safety. Several studies showed a link between excessive work hours and occurrence of medical incidents related to tiredness. However published data do not show a link between tiredness and patients endangering. The tiredness resulting from sleep deprivation and disturbances in circadian rhythms is a cumulative phenomenon erased by a period of rest. In spite of a large individual variability, tiredness increases anxiety scores, irritability, depression and it deteriorates cognitive performances. The concept of "prophylactic" rest considers that a subject cannot start, rested, a work if he did not sleep at least 5 hours the previous night, or 12 hours during the previous 48 hours. The second important aspect of the rest for safety is the long-term prevention of potential pathologies in medical staff, in particular burnout syndrome. In our profession, night calls are considered most stressful; the psychological stress related to anticipation and night context causes measurable cardiovascular disturbances in anesthesiologists. Shift-work sleep disorders may induce gastric ulcers, heart attacks, metabolic syndrome, depression and accidents related to somnolence. Long duration work-hours, accompanied by sleep deprivation, may double the risk of car accidents in junior physicians, in whom vigilance levels can compare with those of patients concerned by narcolepsy or with the cognitive disturbances induced by alcohol intoxication. Reduced work-hours improve vigilance and divide by three the rate of serious medical errors. True opportunities of sleep and control of sleep duration at the individual level could be suggested. The idea that taking the necessary rest would be synonymous with a decrease of efficiency in patient care is not demonstrated, but the danger of a poorer information transmission should be handed with an optimization of our manpower and organization. Aging is accompanied by a progressive disorganization of sleep. The foreseeable shortage of manpower, synonymous with aging of the medical actors and increased vulnerability to tiredness, is a posteriori the justification of the institution of the rest for safety.
2003年,美国(经美国毕业后医学教育认证委员会批准)和法国(2001年1月9日和2001年9月14日)颁布了关于休息与安全的规定。“安全休息”制度,即在夜间值班后立即进行长达11小时的活动中断,可以被视为在寻求安全方面的一项进步。多项研究表明,工作时间过长与因疲劳导致的医疗事故发生之间存在关联。然而,已发表的数据并未显示疲劳与危及患者安全之间存在联系。睡眠剥夺和昼夜节律紊乱导致的疲劳是一种累积现象,可通过一段时间的休息消除。尽管个体差异很大,但疲劳会增加焦虑评分、易怒、抑郁程度,并会降低认知能力。“预防性”休息的概念认为,如果一个人前一晚睡眠不足5小时,或在前48小时内睡眠不足12小时,就不能在休息好的状态下开始工作。安全休息的第二个重要方面是对医务人员潜在疾病的长期预防,尤其是职业倦怠综合征。在我们这个行业,夜间值班被认为压力最大;与预期和夜间环境相关的心理压力会在麻醉医生身上引发可测量的心血管紊乱。轮班工作睡眠障碍可能诱发胃溃疡、心脏病发作、代谢综合征、抑郁症以及与嗜睡相关的事故。长时间工作且伴有睡眠剥夺,可能会使年轻医生发生车祸的风险增加一倍,他们的警觉水平可能与发作性睡病患者相当,或者与酒精中毒引起的认知障碍相当。减少工作时间可提高警觉性,并将严重医疗差错率降低至三分之一。可以提出在个人层面保证真正的睡眠机会并控制睡眠时间的建议。认为进行必要的休息就等同于降低患者护理效率的观点并未得到证实,但在优化人力和组织的同时,应注意信息传递不畅的风险。衰老伴随着睡眠的逐渐紊乱。可预见的人力短缺,这与医疗从业者的老龄化以及对疲劳的易感性增加同义,事后证明了设立安全休息制度的合理性。