Bluford Dontrell A A, Sherry Bettylou, Scanlon Kelley S
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Atlanta, GA, USA.
Obesity (Silver Spring). 2007 Jun;15(6):1356-72. doi: 10.1038/oby.2007.163.
To identify effective programs to prevent or treat overweight among 2- to <6-year-old children.
We searched six databases to identify evaluated intervention programs assessing changes in weight status or body fat and systematically summarized study attributes and outcomes.
Four of the seven studies (two intervention, two prevention) documented significant reductions in weight status or body fat. Among these, three sustained reductions at 1 or 2 years after program initiation, three incorporated a framework/theory, two actively and one passively involved parents, three included multicomponent strategies, and all four monitored behavioral changes. Of the three (prevention) studies that did not show reduction in weight or fat status, all performed assessments between 4 and 9 months after program initiation, and one used a multicomponent strategy. Other significant changes reported were reductions in television viewing, cholesterol, and parental restriction of child feeding.
The paucity of studies limits our ability to generalize findings. Among the available studies, multicomponent programs with 1- to 2-year follow-up in clinics or child care settings were successful in their impact on weight; they were likely enhanced by parental involvement. Both treatment programs and two of five prevention programs reduced weight/fat status. Our review highlights the need to evaluate more programs, advocate for use of a framework/behavioral theory and objective behavioral measures, further examine the impact of involving parents and the impact of intervention duration and follow-up time, strengthen prevention programs, and further evaluate successful programs in other settings and among other racial/ethnic groups.
确定预防或治疗2至6岁儿童超重的有效方案。
我们检索了六个数据库,以找出评估体重状况或体脂变化的已评估干预方案,并系统总结研究特征和结果。
七项研究中的四项(两项干预研究、两项预防研究)记录了体重状况或体脂的显著降低。其中,三项在方案启动后1年或2年保持了体重降低,三项纳入了一个框架/理论,两项积极且一项被动地让家长参与,三项采用了多组分策略,并且所有四项都监测了行为变化。在三项未显示体重或脂肪状况降低的(预防)研究中,所有研究均在方案启动后4至9个月进行评估,且一项采用了多组分策略。报告的其他显著变化包括看电视时间减少、胆固醇降低以及家长对儿童喂养的限制减少。
研究数量不足限制了我们对研究结果进行推广的能力。在现有研究中,在诊所或儿童保育场所进行1至2年随访的多组分方案对体重有成功影响;家长参与可能增强了这种影响。治疗方案和五项预防方案中的两项降低了体重/脂肪状况。我们的综述强调需要评估更多方案,提倡使用框架/行为理论和客观行为测量方法,进一步研究家长参与的影响以及干预持续时间和随访时间的影响,加强预防方案,并在其他环境和其他种族/族裔群体中进一步评估成功的方案。