Levett-Jones Tracy, Lathlean Judith, McMillan Margaret, Higgins Isabel
School of Nursing & Midwifery, The University of Newcastle, Callaghan NSW, Australia, and Honorary Research Associate, The University of Southampton, Southampton, United Kingdom.
Contemp Nurse. 2007 Apr;24(2):162-74. doi: 10.5172/conu.2007.24.2.162.
The psychological and social sciences literature is replete with assertions that human beings are fundamentally and pervasively motivated by the need to belong. This paper reports on some of the findings from the qualitative phase of a mixed-method, multi-site study that explored nursing students' experience of belongingness while on clinical placements. Students from Australia and the United Kingdom were interviewed to identify factors that impact upon and are consequences of belongingness. A montage of participants' stories is used to illustrate some of the key features of clinical workplaces that are conducive to the development of belongingness. Contextual factors and interpersonal dynamics were seen to have a significant bearing on students' experiences. Clinical leaders/managers who were welcoming, accepting and supportive, and nursing staff who were inclusive and encouraging, facilitated students' perception of being valued and respected as members of the nursing team. Additionally, the provision of consistent, quality mentorship was identified as important to students' feelings of connectedness and fit. The experience of belongingness, in turn, enhanced students' potential for learning and influenced their future career decisions. Alternatively, alienation resulted from unreceptive and unwelcoming clinical environments and from the dissonance created when students' personal and professional values did not articulate with those evident in practice environments. Consequently, distress, detachment and disengagement occurred and students' capacity and motivation for learning was negatively impacted.
人类的根本和普遍动机是归属感的需求。本文报告了一项混合方法、多地点研究的定性阶段的一些研究结果,该研究探讨了护理专业学生在临床实习期间的归属感体验。对来自澳大利亚和英国的学生进行了访谈,以确定影响归属感以及作为归属感结果的因素。通过参与者故事的蒙太奇手法,来说明有利于培养归属感的临床工作场所的一些关键特征。情境因素和人际动态被认为对学生的体验有重大影响。热情、接纳和支持的临床领导/管理人员,以及包容和鼓励的护理人员,促进了学生作为护理团队成员被重视和尊重的感觉。此外,提供一致、高质量的指导被认为对学生的联系感和融入感很重要。归属感体验反过来又增强了学生的学习潜力,并影响了他们未来的职业决策。相反,疏离感源于不接纳和不友好的临床环境,以及当学生的个人和职业价值观与实践环境中明显的价值观不一致时所产生的不协调。因此,出现了痛苦、疏离和脱离接触的情况,学生的学习能力和动机受到了负面影响。