Almansa C, Rey E, Bolaños E, Palma M, Alvarez Sánchez A, Díaz-Rubio M
Servicio de Aparato Digestivo, Hospital Clínico San Carlos, Madrid, Spain.
Rev Esp Enferm Dig. 2007 Apr;99(4):210-7. doi: 10.4321/s1130-01082007000400005.
lack of evidence in most clinical situations regarding irritable bowel syndrome (IBS) enhances the importance of an expert s opinion, which will guide management and even the concept underlying the disease.
to delve into the knowledge and degree of agreement on main clinical skills for this syndrome among physicians involved in its management.
two rounds of a Delphi survey were conducted on 100 physicians: general practitioners (GPs) and gastroenterologists. The questionnaire evaluated agreement among participants in some aspects regarding the definition, diagnosis, and treatment of IBS.
fifty-five percent of participants completed the two-round survey. Agreement was achieved regarding the definition of typical symptoms and red flags characterizing IBS. Although there was no consensus regarding the appropriate management of patients without alarm symptoms, the performance of a colonoscopy on any patient presenting red flags was suggested. Patients were thought to require a wider examination when older than 40. A well defined line of IBS treatment was not found, albeit most physicians tended to choose it depending on the main complaint.
interviewed physicians showed adequate theoretical knowledge of IBS, but lack of uniformity on diagnosis and treatment approach reflects the controversial day-by-day management of this syndrome.
在大多数临床情况下,关于肠易激综合征(IBS)的证据不足,这凸显了专家意见的重要性,专家意见将指导治疗以及该疾病的潜在概念。
深入探究参与该综合征管理的医生对其主要临床技能的了解程度和共识。
对100名医生(全科医生和胃肠病学家)进行了两轮德尔菲调查。问卷评估了参与者在IBS的定义、诊断和治疗等方面的共识。
55%的参与者完成了两轮调查。就IBS典型症状的定义和警示信号达成了共识。尽管对于无警示症状患者的适当管理没有达成共识,但建议对任何出现警示信号的患者进行结肠镜检查。当患者年龄超过40岁时,认为需要进行更广泛的检查。尽管大多数医生倾向于根据主要症状选择治疗方法,但未发现明确的IBS治疗方案。
受访医生对IBS有足够的理论知识,但在诊断和治疗方法上缺乏一致性,这反映了该综合征日常管理存在争议。