Qi You-fei, Zhu Shai-hong, Liu Xun-yang, Liu Bo, Li Rui-zhen, Zhou Ping, Wang Guo-hui
Department of General Surgery, Third Xiangya Hospital, Central South University, 410013, China.
Zhong Nan Da Xue Xue Bao Yi Xue Ban. 2007 Jun;32(3):368-72.
To assess the efficacy of endoscopic variceal ligation (EVL) combined with Hassab's procedure in the prevention of variceal recurrence.
One hundred and thirty-five patients with esophageal varices were randomized to receive EVL alone, Hassab's procedure alone or a combination of EVL and Hassab's procedure for variceal eradication. Ultrasonographic venous network images were recorded by an esophageal microprobe before and after the EVL or Hassab's procedure. The clinical outcome and vascular network images of the 3 groups were analyzed.
Esophageal varices were obliterated immediately after EVL alone, while both perforating veins and periesophageal collaterals remained patent, and 83% had recurrence of esophageal varices during an initial 3-year follow-up. Esophageal varices were reduced in size, periesophageal collaterals were obliterated after Hassab's procedure alone, and 30% experienced rebleeding and 95% with variceal recurrence. EVL combined with Hassab's procedure obliterated all esophageal varices, perforating veins and periesophageal collaterals, and only 3 patients (8%) recurred.
The existence of patent perforating veins and periesophageal collaterals is the reason of esophageal variceal recurrence after EVL alone. EVL combined with Hassab's procedure can effectively prevent the recurrence, even if the cirrhojtic portal hypertension persisted.
评估内镜下静脉曲张套扎术(EVL)联合哈萨布手术在预防静脉曲张复发中的疗效。
135例食管静脉曲张患者被随机分为单独接受EVL组、单独接受哈萨布手术组或接受EVL与哈萨布手术联合治疗以消除静脉曲张组。在EVL或哈萨布手术前后,用食管微型探头记录超声静脉网络图像。分析3组的临床结果和血管网络图像。
单独行EVL后食管静脉曲张立即消失,但穿支静脉和食管周围侧支均保持通畅,在最初3年的随访中83%的患者食管静脉曲张复发。单独行哈萨布手术后食管静脉曲张尺寸减小,食管周围侧支消失,30%的患者再次出血,95%的患者静脉曲张复发。EVL联合哈萨布手术使所有食管静脉曲张、穿支静脉和食管周围侧支均消失,只有3例患者(8%)复发。
穿支静脉和食管周围侧支通畅是单独行EVL后食管静脉曲张复发的原因。EVL联合哈萨布手术可有效预防复发,即使肝硬化门静脉高压持续存在。