Wilson Sam, Eagles John M, Platt Julie E, McKenzie Hamish
Royal Cornhill Hospital, Aberdeen, UK.
Med Educ. 2007 Jul;41(7):698-702. doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2923.2007.02790.x.
The purpose of this study is to define the most relevant topics for inclusion in an undergraduate psychiatric curriculum by asking non-psychiatrists what knowledge, skills and attitudes related to psychiatry they need in their day-to-day practice.
A questionnaire study involving non-psychiatric doctors (based both in hospitals and general practice) was carried out using Delphi methodology in 2 waves. In the first wave, 408 doctors described the psychiatric competencies they required in their current posts. From this, a list of 101 psychiatric topics was generated. In the second wave, 867 doctors rated these topics according to the relevance of each topic to their practice.
Depression, alcohol misuse and drug misuse were rated as most relevant. General practitioners found more topics relevant to their practice than did hospital doctors, and there were disparities in the relative importance that the 2 groups gave to topics.
This study demonstrates a systematic method for developing core curricular undergraduate learning objectives in a specialty area by asking doctors outside that specialty to identify topics that are relevant to their practice. Similar methods could be used for a range of specialties other than psychiatry and could provide a rational and transparent means of developing a core curriculum for medical students, when combined with perspectives from other sources.
本研究旨在通过询问非精神科医生在日常实践中所需的与精神病学相关的知识、技能和态度,来确定本科精神病学课程中最相关的主题。
采用德尔菲法分两波对非精神科医生(包括医院医生和全科医生)进行问卷调查研究。在第一波中,408名医生描述了他们当前岗位所需的精神病学能力。据此生成了一份包含101个精神病学主题的清单。在第二波中,867名医生根据每个主题与他们实践的相关性对这些主题进行评分。
抑郁症、酒精滥用和药物滥用被评为最相关。与医院医生相比,全科医生发现更多与他们实践相关的主题,并且两组对主题的相对重要性存在差异。
本研究展示了一种系统的方法,通过询问该专业以外的医生来确定与他们实践相关的主题,从而制定本科专业领域的核心课程学习目标。除精神病学外,类似方法可用于一系列其他专业,并且与其他来源的观点相结合时,可为医学生制定核心课程提供合理且透明的方式。