Boxerman Jerrold L, Hawash Karameh, Bali Bhavna, Clarke Tara, Rogg Jeffrey, Pal Deb K
Department of Diagnostic Imaging, Rhode Island Hospital, Providence, RI, USA.
Epilepsy Res. 2007 Jul;75(2-3):180-5. doi: 10.1016/j.eplepsyres.2007.06.001.
Rolandic epilepsy (RE) is designated an idiopathic epilepsy syndrome, and hence no lesional abnormalities are expected on MRI exam. Recent reports suggest that MRI abnormalities are not only common, but may be specific for temporal lobe epilepsy, and lateralized to the side of EEG discharges. However, no controlled study has been performed to test the hypothesis of association between MRI abnormalities and Rolandic epilepsy. We performed an unmatched case-control study to test the hypothesis of association between MRI abnormalities and Rolandic epilepsy, using 25 typical RE cases and 25 children with migraine. Two independent examiners rated the MRIs for abnormalities. Examiners were blinded to the study hypothesis and identity of case and control exams. Fifty-two percent of RE exams contained at least one abnormality: peri/hippocampal abnormality (one case), non-localized congenital malformation (seven cases), subcortical parenchymal hyperintensities (two cases), periventricular parenchymal hyperintensities (one case), dilated perivascular spaces (six cases). There was no difference between the number or type of abnormalities in cases and controls. No type of abnormality lateralized to the hemisphere from which the EEG spikes emanated. The odds ratio of association between MRI abnormalities and RE was 0.87, 95% CI: 0.18-4.33 after adjusting for potential demographic and technical factors. We conclude that routine cranial MRI abnormalities are common in RE, but no more common than in controls, and not specific for RE.
罗兰多癫痫(RE)被认定为一种特发性癫痫综合征,因此在MRI检查中预计不会有病变异常。最近的报告表明,MRI异常不仅常见,而且可能是颞叶癫痫所特有的,并且与脑电图放电侧别一致。然而,尚未进行对照研究来检验MRI异常与罗兰多癫痫之间关联的假设。我们进行了一项非匹配病例对照研究,以检验MRI异常与罗兰多癫痫之间关联的假设,使用了25例典型RE病例和25例偏头痛儿童。两名独立的检查人员对MRI的异常情况进行评分。检查人员对研究假设以及病例和对照检查的身份不知情。52%的RE检查至少包含一项异常:海马旁/海马异常(1例)、非定位性先天性畸形(7例)、皮质下实质高信号(2例)、脑室周围实质高信号(1例)、血管周围间隙增宽(6例)。病例组和对照组在异常的数量或类型上没有差异。没有任何一种异常与脑电图棘波发出的半球侧别一致。在对潜在的人口统计学和技术因素进行调整后,MRI异常与RE之间关联的优势比为0.87,95%可信区间:0.18 - 4.33。我们得出结论,常规头颅MRI异常在RE中很常见,但并不比对照组更常见,也不是RE所特有的。