Menif Khaled, Hamdi Asma, Khaldi Ammar, Bouziri Asma, Kazdaghli Kalthoum, Bel Hadj Sarra, Kechrid Amel, Ben Jaballah Najla
Service de Réanimation Pédiatrique Polyvalente, Hôpital d'enfants de Tunis.
Tunis Med. 2007 May;85(5):371-5.
To evaluate the diagnostic delay and therapeutic insufficiencies delay before the transfer in ICU of the children admitted in the ICU of the children's hospital of Tunis with a purpura fulminans (PF).
A retrospective, descriptive study, of children with PF referred between January 2000 and January 2006 to a the paediatric intensive care unit (PICU) of the children's hospital of Tunis. The PF diagnosis was retained in any child presenting a feverish purpura and circulatory insufficiency signs. The optimal diagnostic and therapeutic charge taking was defined in three levels: parental, the first line doctors, and the hospital doctors. The symptoms' duration and the various treatments which were lavished to the patients were taken from the medical observations of the patients transferred in our PICU.
Twenty one observations were collected. Twelve patients (57.1%) were addressed by a doctor exerting in a dispensary or by a free practicing doctor, 5 patients (23.8%) were transferred from a regional hospital and 4 children (19.1%) directly consulted the children hospital of Tunis urgencies delayed parental recognition occured in 11 children. The PF diagnosis was not evoked by the first line doctor in 62%. Eleven (52.4%) of the children with meningococcal disease were seen but not admitted by a doctor in the 48 hours before admission. Apart from 2 patients (9.5%) who were hospitalized in reanimation directly of the urgencies, all the other patients forwarded by a general pediatry service. In general pediatry, the PF diagnosis was not evoked in 3 cases (15.8%), 31.6% of patients had unnecessary a lumbar punctures and shock was not recognised or treated in 26.3%. Twelve patients (52.2%) died. The duration of hospitalization in general pediatry is significantly higher among deceased patients (5.5 +/- 6.6 hours) than among the surviving patients (2.6 +/- 1.5 hours); p < 0.05.
Suboptimal treatement in PF is due to failure of parents, general practioners and hospital doctors to recognise specific features of the illness. Improvement in outcome could be achieved by public education and better training of clinicians in recognition, resuscitation, and stabilisation of seriously ill children.
评估突尼斯儿童医院重症监护病房(ICU)收治的暴发性紫癜(PF)患儿转入ICU前的诊断延迟和治疗不足延迟情况。
对2000年1月至2006年1月转诊至突尼斯儿童医院儿科重症监护病房(PICU)的PF患儿进行一项回顾性描述性研究。PF诊断适用于任何出现发热性紫癜和循环功能不全体征的患儿。最佳诊断和治疗收费分为三个级别:家长、一线医生和医院医生。症状持续时间以及给予患者的各种治疗措施取自转入我们PICU的患者的医疗记录。
收集到21份病例。12名患者(57.1%)由在诊所执业的医生或自由执业医生诊治,5名患者(23.8%)从地区医院转诊而来,4名儿童(19.1%)直接到突尼斯儿童医院急诊就诊。11名儿童出现家长识别延迟。62%的一线医生未考虑PF诊断。11名(52.4%)患脑膜炎球菌病的儿童在入院前48小时内被医生诊治但未收治。除2名患者(9.5%)直接在急诊复苏病房住院外,所有其他患者由普通儿科服务转诊。在普通儿科,3例(15.8%)未考虑PF诊断,31.6%的患者进行了不必要的腰椎穿刺,26.3%的患者休克未被识别或治疗。12名患者(52.2%)死亡。死亡患者在普通儿科的住院时间(5.5±6.6小时)显著长于存活患者(2.6±1.5小时);p<0.05。
PF治疗欠佳是由于家长、全科医生和医院医生未能识别该疾病的特定特征。通过公众教育以及对临床医生进行更好的识别、复苏和稳定重症儿童方面的培训,可改善治疗结果。