Morrow Thomas
Value-Based health Care, Genentech, Inc., 320 Pilgrimage Point, Alpharetta, GA 30022, USA.
J Manag Care Pharm. 2007 Jul-Aug;13(6):497-505. doi: 10.18553/jmcp.2007.13.6.497.
For more than a generation, managed care has attempted to eliminate variation in care delivery in the hope of producing predictable outcomes. But the population-based, guideline-driven approach may not have fully appreciated the importance of individual behavior (adherence) and environment, as well as individual genetic makeup. Genetic variation in response to currently recommended therapies may require tailoring medication regimens to the individual patient to achieve optimal outcomes.
To review the pharmacogenomics of asthma and how they impact the medications utilized for its treatment.
A search of PubMed that included the time period from January 1991 through September 2005 and the key terms: asthma pharmacogenetics, asthma genetics, asthma response variability, asthma glucocorticoid resistance, asthma steroid-unresponsive, asthma control, beta-agonist genomics, beta 2-receptor abnormalities, asthma genotypes, and leukotriene inhibitor polymorphisms produced 105 articles. Forty-five were rejected for this subject review by failing the following criteria: (1) results in humans, not animals, (2) provide information about clinical implications as well as description of molecular and cellular mechanism of action or the site of action on the gene, and (3) preference for manuscripts that quantified information/ results over those that just stated that there were observed differences. The remaining 60 references were reviewed, and 7 references were added after peer review.
There are now limited examples of gene polymorphisms that can influence responses to beta 2-agonists, glucocorticosteroids, and leukotriene modifiers in patients with asthma. Gene mutations that are known to alter the response to asthma therapy include Arg/Arg atr position 16, mutations of LTC4S, ALOX5, and GR/NR3C1, increased expression of GR , CRHR1 variants, and mutations in CYP1A2 (-22964 [G/A]), and T 314 allele for histamine N-methyltransferase. Some of the effects associated with these mutations are increased/decreased response to therapy, glucocorticoid resistance, decreased theophylline clearance and possible toxicity, and increased bronchoconstriction.
Understanding the impact of genetic variations on response to therapy may ultimately improve treatment outcomes for patients with asthma. However, despite substantial progress, no individual gene polymorphisms have been associated with altered responses to asthma treatment in large numbers of patients. It is not yet possible to tailor medication therapy for asthma based on genetic characteristics of individual patients.
在过去的一代人多的时间里,管理式医疗一直试图消除医疗服务中的差异,以期产生可预测的结果。但是,基于人群、遵循指南的方法可能并未充分认识到个体行为(依从性)、环境以及个体基因构成的重要性。目前推荐疗法的反应中的基因变异可能需要根据个体患者量身定制药物治疗方案,以实现最佳疗效。
综述哮喘的药物基因组学及其如何影响用于治疗哮喘的药物。
检索PubMed,检索时间段为1991年1月至2005年9月,检索关键词为:哮喘药物遗传学、哮喘遗传学、哮喘反应变异性、哮喘糖皮质激素抵抗、哮喘对类固醇无反应、哮喘控制、β-激动剂基因组学、β2-受体异常、哮喘基因型和白三烯抑制剂多态性,共检索到105篇文章。其中45篇因未满足以下标准而被排除在本主题综述之外:(1)研究结果来自人类而非动物;(2)提供临床意义信息以及分子和细胞作用机制或基因作用位点的描述;(3)优先选择对信息/结果进行量化的手稿,而非仅表明观察到差异的手稿。对其余60篇参考文献进行了综述,并在同行评审后又增加了7篇参考文献。
目前已知有限的基因多态性实例可影响哮喘患者对β2-激动剂、糖皮质激素和白三烯调节剂的反应。已知会改变对哮喘治疗反应的基因突变包括第16位的精氨酸/精氨酸、白三烯C4合成酶(LTC4S)、5-脂氧合酶(ALOX5)和糖皮质激素受体/核受体亚家族3成员C1(GR/NR3C1)的突变、GR表达增加、促肾上腺皮质激素释放激素受体1(CRHR1)变体以及细胞色素P450 1A2(-22964 [G/A])的突变,以及组胺N-甲基转移酶的T314等位基因。与这些突变相关的一些影响包括治疗反应增加/减少、糖皮质激素抵抗、茶碱清除率降低和可能的毒性以及支气管收缩增加。
了解基因变异对治疗反应的影响最终可能改善哮喘患者的治疗效果。然而,尽管取得了重大进展,但尚未发现大量患者中存在与哮喘治疗反应改变相关的个体基因多态性。目前还无法根据个体患者的基因特征为哮喘量身定制药物治疗。